Formation and Stability of Bulk Nanobubbles in Different Solutions.

The existence of bulk nanobubbles is still controversial in spite of their significance in a large range of applications. Here, we developed a new method of compression-decompression to produce controllably bulk nanobubbles. Then, we further investigated the generation of bulk nanobubbles in pure water, acid, alkaline, and salt solutions using nanoparticle tracking analysis. The results indicated that the concentration of bulk nanobubbles depends on the decompression time and would reach a maximum value when the decompression time is about 30 min for the pure water system. More importantly, we gave a relatively direct evidence of the existence of bulk nanobubbles by measuring the X-ray fluorescence intensity of Kr in acid, alkaline, and salt solutions. It is shown that the decrease tendency in intensity of Kr in alkaline solution is similar to that in the concentration of bulk nanobubbles with the deposited time, indicating that the bulk nanobubbles produced indeed have gas inside. Furthermore, the concentration and stability of bulk nanobubbles in an alkaline solution are greatest compared with other two solutions regardless of gas types. The concentration of bulk nanobubbles will decrease in the order alkaline > acid/pure water > salt solutions. We believe that our results should be very helpful in understanding the formation and stability of bulk nanobubbles in different solutions.