Effects of online repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) on cognitive processing: A meta-analysis and recommendations for future studies.
Cognition
Meta-analysis
Online rTMS
Journal
Neuroscience and biobehavioral reviews
ISSN: 1873-7528
Titre abrégé: Neurosci Biobehav Rev
Pays: United States
ID NLM: 7806090
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
12 2019
12 2019
Historique:
received:
06
05
2019
revised:
28
06
2019
accepted:
22
08
2019
pubmed:
2
9
2019
medline:
30
7
2020
entrez:
2
9
2019
Statut:
ppublish
Résumé
Online repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), applied while subjects are performing a task, is widely used to disrupt brain regions underlying cognition. However, online rTMS has also induced "paradoxical enhancement". Given the rapid proliferation of this approach, it is crucial to develop a better understanding of how online stimulation influences cognition, and the optimal parameters to achieve desired effects. To accomplish this goal, a quantitative meta-analysis was performed with random-effects models fitted to reaction time (RT) and accuracy data. The final dataset included 126 studies published between 1998 and 2016, with 244 total effects for reaction times, and 202 for accuracy. Meta-analytically, rTMS at 10 Hz and 20 Hz disrupted accuracy for attention, executive, language, memory, motor, and perception domains, while no effects were found with 1 Hz or 5 Hz. Stimulation applied at and 10 and 20 Hz slowed down RTs in attention and perception tasks. No performance enhancement was found. Meta-regression analysis showed that fMRI-guided targeting and short inter-trial intervals are associated with increased disruptive effects with rTMS.
Identifiants
pubmed: 31473301
pii: S0149-7634(19)30383-5
doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.08.018
pmc: PMC7654714
mid: NIHMS1643853
pii:
doi:
Types de publication
Journal Article
Meta-Analysis
Research Support, N.I.H., Extramural
Research Support, N.I.H., Intramural
Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't
Review
Langues
eng
Sous-ensembles de citation
IM
Pagination
47-58Subventions
Organisme : NIA NIH HHS
ID : U01 AG050618
Pays : United States
Informations de copyright
Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Références
J Neurosci. 2008 Sep 3;28(36):8929-33
pubmed: 18768686
Curr Biol. 2007 Sep 18;17(18):1568-73
pubmed: 17764942
Neuropsychologia. 2006;44(7):1222-9
pubmed: 16490222
Exp Brain Res. 2006 Jan;168(1-2):265-71
pubmed: 16078022
Neuroreport. 2002 May 7;13(6):809-11
pubmed: 11997692
PLoS One. 2013 Dec 20;8(12):e80256
pubmed: 24376494
PLoS One. 2012;7(8):e43731
pubmed: 22937085
J Neurosci. 2012 Nov 7;32(45):15877-85
pubmed: 23136426
J Cogn Neurosci. 2013 Jun;25(6):961-8
pubmed: 23410031
Front Hum Neurosci. 2012 Feb 20;6:20
pubmed: 22363279
Exp Brain Res. 2005 Jan;160(3):404-8
pubmed: 15645228
Cereb Cortex. 2013 Jul;23(7):1517-25
pubmed: 22661410
J Cogn Neurosci. 2008 May;20(5):916-26
pubmed: 18201128
Cereb Cortex. 2008 Sep;18(9):2077-85
pubmed: 18203694
Hum Brain Mapp. 2009 Dec;30(12):3851-64
pubmed: 19441022
J Cogn Neurosci. 2003 Apr 1;15(3):315-23
pubmed: 12729485
Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1989 Nov-Dec;74(6):458-62
pubmed: 2480226
Neuroimage. 2012 Feb 1;59(3):3015-20
pubmed: 22023740
Exp Brain Res. 1998 Jan;118(2):197-204
pubmed: 9547088
J Cogn Neurosci. 2008 Jan;20(1):170-81
pubmed: 17919080
J Cogn Neurosci. 2007 Jun;19(6):1013-20
pubmed: 17536971
Neuroimage. 2005 Jan 1;24(1):34-9
pubmed: 15588594
Curr Biol. 2004 Dec 14;14(23):2130-4
pubmed: 15589156
Neuropsychologia. 2013 Jul;51(8):1528-33
pubmed: 23665379
Neuroimage. 2003 Oct;20(2):1032-41
pubmed: 14568473
Front Psychol. 2011 Jul 20;2:170
pubmed: 21811485
Brain Stimul. 2016 Jul-Aug;9(4):574-6
pubmed: 27033011
BMC Neurosci. 2010 Aug 10;11:93
pubmed: 20698964
Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2015 Mar;10(3):342-51
pubmed: 24771282
J Cogn Neurosci. 2006 Oct;18(10):1666-75
pubmed: 17014372
Exp Brain Res. 2016 Sep;234(9):2447-55
pubmed: 27083589
Brain Cogn. 2016 Apr;104:72-81
pubmed: 26970943
Neuropsychologia. 2015 Jul;74:42-9
pubmed: 25541500
J Neurophysiol. 2014 Feb;111(4):705-14
pubmed: 24259544
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2015 May 17;12:47
pubmed: 25981522
Exp Brain Res. 2006 Nov;175(4):618-25
pubmed: 16819647
J Neurosci. 2013 Mar 13;33(11):5000-5
pubmed: 23486970
Int J Biomed Imaging. 2008;2008:143238
pubmed: 18350118
Exp Brain Res. 2014 Apr;232(4):1267-81
pubmed: 24496490
J Cogn Neurosci. 2013 Sep;25(9):1453-62
pubmed: 23647519
Clin Neurophysiol. 2014 Jun;125(6):1202-12
pubmed: 24411523
Curr Biol. 2007 Apr 17;17(8):689-93
pubmed: 17379521
Front Hum Neurosci. 2012 Feb 01;6:2
pubmed: 22347175
Cortex. 2015 Mar;64:318-26
pubmed: 25584788
Neurosci Lett. 2002 Mar 1;320(1-2):5-8
pubmed: 11849750
Clin Neurophysiol. 2011 May;122(5):1011-8
pubmed: 20869307
J Neuropsychol. 2009 Mar;3(Pt 1):31-43
pubmed: 19338715
Behav Brain Res. 2011 Jan 1;216(1):153-8
pubmed: 20667492
Neurology. 1991 May;41(5):697-702
pubmed: 2027485
J Cogn Neurosci. 2011 Oct;23(10):2782-96
pubmed: 21254798
J Neurosci. 2013 Jan 23;33(4):1331-6a
pubmed: 23345209
Nat Neurosci. 2005 Sep;8(9):1228-33
pubmed: 16056222
Curr Biol. 2012 Aug 21;22(16):R658-63
pubmed: 22917517
Clin Neurophysiol. 2006 Dec;117(12):2584-96
pubmed: 16890483
J Cogn Neurosci. 2015 Nov;27(11):2117-25
pubmed: 26102225
Clin Neurophysiol. 2010 Mar;121(3):426-30
pubmed: 20006546
J Neurol Sci. 2000 Dec 1;181(1-2):50-5
pubmed: 11099712
Cortex. 2008 Mar;44(3):337-44
pubmed: 18387562
Cereb Cortex. 2001 Oct;11(10):918-23
pubmed: 11549614
Brain Stimul. 2012 Oct;5(4):526-32
pubmed: 21962979
J Neurosci. 2012 Mar 7;32(10):3447-52
pubmed: 22399767
Cortex. 2015 Mar;64:310-7
pubmed: 25577719
Front Hum Neurosci. 2018 Jan 04;11:638
pubmed: 29354043
Brain Behav. 2015 Mar;5(3):e00317
pubmed: 25642395
PLoS One. 2008 Jun 25;3(6):e2481
pubmed: 18575615
Neuroimage. 2013 Jul 1;74:45-51
pubmed: 23435211
Neuroreport. 2009 Oct 28;20(16):1496-9
pubmed: 19809371
Eur J Neurosci. 2003 Mar;17(5):1129-33
pubmed: 12653991
Neuropsychologia. 2015 Aug;75:143-8
pubmed: 26026256
Neuropsychologia. 2005;43(2):189-98
pubmed: 15707904
Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2011 Jan;6(1):58-65
pubmed: 20194516
Neuron. 2005 Jan 20;45(2):201-6
pubmed: 15664172
Clin Neurophysiol. 2009 Dec;120(12):2008-2039
pubmed: 19833552
Cortex. 2012 May;48(5):623-9
pubmed: 21722888
Brain Cogn. 2011 Oct;77(1):120-7
pubmed: 21620548
J Neurosci. 2014 Sep 10;34(37):12481-9
pubmed: 25209286
Neuroscience. 2010 Mar 17;166(2):501-7
pubmed: 20034547
Clin Neurophysiol. 2002 Sep;113(9):1501-4
pubmed: 12169333
Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry. 2019 Mar 8;89:347-360
pubmed: 30312634
Brain Stimul. 2016 Jul-Aug;9(4):594-600
pubmed: 27210036
J Cogn Neurosci. 2011 Jun;23(6):1358-67
pubmed: 20617889
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010 Sep 21;107(38):16494-9
pubmed: 20807747
Hum Brain Mapp. 2011 Sep;32(9):1471-82
pubmed: 21077146
Brain Stimul. 2015 Jul-Aug;8(4):816-22
pubmed: 25753177
Front Integr Neurosci. 2009 Jun 24;3:14
pubmed: 19587850
J Neurosci. 2013 Mar 27;33(13):5647-54
pubmed: 23536079
BMJ. 1997 Sep 13;315(7109):629-34
pubmed: 9310563
Nat Neurosci. 2001 Sep;4(9):948-52
pubmed: 11528428
Int Rev Psychiatry. 2017 Apr;29(2):115-145
pubmed: 28443696
Cortex. 2013 Sep;49(8):2097-105
pubmed: 23313011
Hum Brain Mapp. 2013 Feb;34(2):356-66
pubmed: 22042759
Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1997 Dec;105(6):415-21
pubmed: 9448642
Cereb Cortex. 2014 Mar;24(3):745-53
pubmed: 23175454
Clin Neurophysiol. 2006 Apr;117(4):838-44
pubmed: 16495145
Neuropsychologia. 2001;39(4):415-9
pubmed: 11164880
J Cogn Neurosci. 2012 Dec;24(12):2363-71
pubmed: 22905824
J Cogn Neurosci. 2009 Feb;21(2):403-14
pubmed: 18510439
Neuroimage. 2011 Feb 14;54(4):3048-56
pubmed: 21073958
J Cogn Neurosci. 2007 Jul;19(7):1140-51
pubmed: 17583990
Neuropsychologia. 2016 Apr;84:193-7
pubmed: 26916969
PLoS One. 2019 Mar 22;14(3):e0213707
pubmed: 30901345
Brain Res. 2009 Mar 31;1263:78-86
pubmed: 19368832
Sleep. 2013 Jun 01;36(6):857-71
pubmed: 23729929
Eur J Neurosci. 2011 Jun;33(11):2155-67
pubmed: 21645109
Brain Cogn. 2013 Dec;83(3):245-51
pubmed: 24077427
Neuroimage. 2012 Jan 2;59(1):840-5
pubmed: 21839180
Exp Brain Res. 2010 Jul;204(2):181-7
pubmed: 20567808
Neuroimage. 2002 Nov;17(3):1512-20
pubmed: 12414290
Brain Res. 2008 Sep 16;1230:202-10
pubmed: 18662678
Brain Stimul. 2015 Sep-Oct;8(5):945-52
pubmed: 26028563
Psychiatry Res. 2002 Oct 1;115(3):101-13
pubmed: 12208488
Neuropsychologia. 2011 Nov;49(13):3648-55
pubmed: 21952193
Brain. 2004 Oct;127(Pt 10):2307-15
pubmed: 15292055
Neuroimage. 2009 Jan 15;44(2):537-45
pubmed: 18852054
Neuropsychologia. 2008 Sep;46(11):2725-31
pubmed: 18573511
J Physiol. 1993 Nov;471:501-19
pubmed: 8120818
BMJ. 2011 Oct 18;343:d5928
pubmed: 22008217
J Neurosci. 2009 May 6;29(18):5863-72
pubmed: 19420253
Brain Res. 2006 Mar 17;1078(1):159-67
pubmed: 16499892
Cereb Cortex. 2010 Nov;20(11):2702-11
pubmed: 20176690
Exp Brain Res. 2000 Aug;133(4):425-30
pubmed: 10985677
Brain Stimul. 2013 Jan;6(1):1-13
pubmed: 22483681
Trends Cogn Sci. 2009 Apr;13(4):182-9
pubmed: 19286414
Neuropsychologia. 2004;42(14):1902-9
pubmed: 15381020
Neuropsychologia. 2010 May;48(6):1807-12
pubmed: 20223254
Brain Topogr. 2016 Jul;29(4):552-60
pubmed: 27021230
Cortex. 2006 Jul;42(5):750-4
pubmed: 16909635
Brain Res Bull. 2007 Mar 15;71(5):523-8
pubmed: 17259022
Exp Brain Res. 1997 Jul;115(3):541-5
pubmed: 9262209
Neuropsychologia. 2008;46(7):2056-63
pubmed: 18336847
Cortex. 2009 Oct;45(9):1097-103
pubmed: 19251255
Neuropsychologia. 2007 Nov 5;45(14):3215-22
pubmed: 17675192
J Neurosci. 2010 Jun 23;30(25):8692-7
pubmed: 20573914
Hum Brain Mapp. 2011 Dec;32(12):2104-14
pubmed: 21305659
Eur J Neurosci. 2011 Sep;34(5):839-44
pubmed: 21864318
Neuroreport. 2004 Nov 15;15(16):2549-52
pubmed: 15538193
Front Behav Neurosci. 2010 Mar 03;4:5
pubmed: 20339485
Cortex. 2009 Oct;45(9):1111-6
pubmed: 19111289
J Neurosci. 2015 Jan 14;35(2):731-8
pubmed: 25589766
J Cogn Neurosci. 2003 Aug 15;15(6):855-61
pubmed: 14511538
PLoS One. 2014 Jul 14;9(7):e102306
pubmed: 25019944
Cereb Cortex. 2010 May;20(5):1037-45
pubmed: 19684247
Eur J Neurosci. 2010 Nov;32(10):1780-7
pubmed: 20946235
Neurosci Lett. 2000 Jun 16;287(1):68-70
pubmed: 10841993
Brain Res. 2009 May 1;1268:112-124
pubmed: 19285972
Neuroimage. 2009 Jun;46(2):522-9
pubmed: 19236924
Curr Biol. 2011 Jul 26;21(14):1176-85
pubmed: 21723129
Neurology. 2002 Sep 10;59(5):720-3
pubmed: 12221163
Brain Res. 2007 Jan 12;1128(1):120-9
pubmed: 17113573
J Cogn Neurosci. 2011 Aug;23(8):1964-72
pubmed: 20849232
Neuroimage. 2016 Jul 15;135:115-24
pubmed: 27153976
Eur J Neurosci. 2003 Mar;17(5):1123-8
pubmed: 12653990
Brain Stimul. 2012 Jan;5(1):11-7
pubmed: 22037138
J Neurosci. 2014 Jul 2;34(27):9173-7
pubmed: 24990937
Neuroimage. 2014 Jan 15;85 Pt 3:961-70
pubmed: 23770409
Exp Biol Med (Maywood). 2011 Feb;236(2):138-44
pubmed: 21321310
J Cogn Neurosci. 2009 Feb;21(2):207-21
pubmed: 18823235
Biol Psychiatry. 2001 Mar 1;49(5):460-3
pubmed: 11274658