Attentional limits in visual search with and without dorsal parietal dysfunction: space-based window or object-based span?

Attentional resource and distribution are specifically impaired in simultanagnosia, and also in the visuo-attentional form of developmental dyslexia. Both clinical conditions are conceived as a limitation of simultaneous visual processing after superior parietal lobule (SPL) dysfunction (review in Valdois et al., 2019). However, a reduced space-based attentional window (i.e. a limited visual eccentricity at which the target object can be identified, Khan et al. 2016) has been demonstrated in simultanagnosia versus a reduced object-based span (i.e. a limited number of objects processed at each fixation, Bosse et al., 2007) in developmental dyslexia. In healthy individuals, the cost in reaction times per item in serial search tasks suggests that a group of objects is processed simultaneously at a time, but this group is also undefined and depends on the visual complexity of the task. Healthy individuals and a patient with simultanagnosia performed serial search tasks involving either symbols (made of separable features) or objects made of non-separable features, and with distractors that were either all identical or all dissimilar. We used a moving window paradigm to determine whether the task was performed with a "working space" versus a "working span" limitation in control group and in patient with bilateral SPL damage. We found that healthy individuals performed search in a color task comprising non-separable feature objects and dissimilar distractors with a limited space-based attentional window; this attentional window, as well as the mean saccade amplitude used to displace it across the visual display, were independent of set size, thus inconsistent with an object-based attentional span. In the symbol task comprising a feature-absent search in which all feature-present distractors were dissimilar, we observed that mean saccade amplitude decreased with set size and that search performance could not be mimicked by a moving window of a single diameter; instead participants seemed to process a fixed number of symbols at a time (object-based span). Following bilateral SPL lesions, patient IG demonstrated a similar space-based search process in the color search task with a normal attentional window. In contrast, her cost-per-item in the symbol task increased dramatically, demonstrating a clear deficit of simultaneous object perception. These results confirmed the specific contribution of the SPL to the visual processing of multiple objects made of separable features (like letters), and more dramatically when they are all different, which explains the specific difficulty for a reading beginner in case of SPL dysfunction.

Informations de copyright

Copyright © 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.