A Core Outcome Set for Trials in Glomerular Disease: A Report of the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Glomerular Disease (SONG-GD) Stakeholder Workshops.
cardiovascular disease
epidemiology and outcomes
glomerular disease
glomerulonephritis
mortality
nephrotic syndrome
outcomes
quality of life
randomized controlled trials
Journal
Clinical journal of the American Society of Nephrology : CJASN
ISSN: 1555-905X
Titre abrégé: Clin J Am Soc Nephrol
Pays: United States
ID NLM: 101271570
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
01 2022
01 2022
Historique:
received:
06
06
2021
accepted:
01
11
2021
pubmed:
1
1
2022
medline:
18
3
2022
entrez:
31
12
2021
Statut:
ppublish
Résumé
Outcomes reported in trials in adults with glomerular disease are often selected with minimal patient input, are heterogeneous, and may not be relevant for clinical decision making. The Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Glomerular Disease (SONG-GD) initiative aimed to establish a core outcome set to help ensure that outcomes of critical importance to patients, care partners, and clinicians are consistently reported. We convened two 1.5-hour workshops in Melbourne, Australia, and Washington, DC, United States. Attendees were identified purposively with 50 patients/care partners and 88 health professionals from 19 countries; 51% were female. Patients and care partners were from the United States, Australia, and Canada, and had experience of a glomerular disease with systemic features ( Three themes were identified that supported the proposed core outcomes: limiting disease progression, stability and control, and ensuring universal relevance ( Workshop themes demonstrated support for kidney function, disease activity, death, life participation, and cardiovascular disease, and these were established as the core outcomes for trials in adults with glomerular disease. Future work is needed to establish the core measures for each domain, with funders and regulators central to the uptake of the core outcome set in trials.
Sections du résumé
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
Outcomes reported in trials in adults with glomerular disease are often selected with minimal patient input, are heterogeneous, and may not be relevant for clinical decision making. The Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Glomerular Disease (SONG-GD) initiative aimed to establish a core outcome set to help ensure that outcomes of critical importance to patients, care partners, and clinicians are consistently reported.
DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, AND MEASUREMENTS
We convened two 1.5-hour workshops in Melbourne, Australia, and Washington, DC, United States. Attendees were identified purposively with 50 patients/care partners and 88 health professionals from 19 countries; 51% were female. Patients and care partners were from the United States, Australia, and Canada, and had experience of a glomerular disease with systemic features (
RESULTS
Three themes were identified that supported the proposed core outcomes: limiting disease progression, stability and control, and ensuring universal relevance (
CONCLUSIONS
Workshop themes demonstrated support for kidney function, disease activity, death, life participation, and cardiovascular disease, and these were established as the core outcomes for trials in adults with glomerular disease. Future work is needed to establish the core measures for each domain, with funders and regulators central to the uptake of the core outcome set in trials.
Identifiants
pubmed: 34969698
pii: 01277230-202201000-00010
doi: 10.2215/CJN.07840621
pmc: PMC8763157
doi:
Types de publication
Journal Article
Research Support, N.I.H., Extramural
Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't
Langues
eng
Sous-ensembles de citation
IM
Pagination
53-64Subventions
Organisme : NIDDK NIH HHS
ID : K08 DK102542
Pays : United States
Organisme : NIDDK NIH HHS
ID : R01 DK126777
Pays : United States
Commentaires et corrections
Type : CommentIn
Informations de copyright
Copyright © 2022 by the American Society of Nephrology.
Références
Howell M, Wong G, Turner RM, Tan HT, Tong A, Craig JC, Howard K: The consistency and reporting of quality-of-life outcomes in trials of immunosuppressive agents in kidney transplantation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Kidney Dis 67: 762–774, 2016
Sautenet B, Tong A, Chapman JR, Warrens AN, Rosenbloom D, Wong G, Gill J, Budde K, Rostaing L, Marson L, Josephson MA, Reese PP, Pruett TL, Evangelidis N, Craig JC: Range and consistency of outcomes reported in randomized trials conducted in kidney transplant recipients: A systematic review. Transplantation 102: 2065–2071, 2018
Sautenet B, Tong A, Williams G, Hemmelgarn BR, Manns B, Wheeler DC, Tugwell P, van Biesen W, Winkelmayer WC, Crowe S, Harris T, Evangelidis N, Hawley CM, Pollock C, Johnson DW, Polkinghorne KR, Howard K, Gallagher MP, Kerr PG, McDonald SP, Ju A, Craig JC: Scope and consistency of outcomes reported in randomized trials conducted in adults receiving hemodialysis: A systematic review. Am J Kidney Dis 72: 62–74, 2018
Chong LSH, Sautenet B, Tong A, Hanson CS, Samuel S, Zappitelli M, Dart A, Furth S, Eddy AA, Groothoff J, Webb NJA, Yap HK, Bockenhauer D, Sinha A, Alexander SI, Goldstein SL, Gipson DS, Raman G, Craig JC: Range and heterogeneity of outcomes in randomized trials of pediatric chronic kidney disease. J Pediatr 186: 110–117.e11, 2017
Sautenet B, Cho Y, Gutman T, Rangan G, Ong A, Chapman AB, Ahn C, Coolican H, Tze-Wah Kao J, Fowler K, Gansevoort RT, Geneste C, Perrone RD, Harris T, Torres VE, Pei Y, Craig JC, Tong A; SONG-PKD Initiative: Range and variability of outcomes reported in randomized trials conducted in patients with polycystic kidney disease: A systematic review. Am J Kidney Dis 76: 213–223, 2020
Clarke M: Standardising outcomes for clinical trials and systematic reviews. Trials 8: 39, 2007
Chadban SJ, Atkins RC: Glomerulonephritis. Lancet 365: 1797–1806, 2005
Wetmore JB, Guo H, Liu J, Collins AJ, Gilbertson DT: The incidence, prevalence, and outcomes of glomerulonephritis derived from a large retrospective analysis. Kidney Int 90: 853–860, 2016
Hermansen ML, Lindhardsen J, Torp-Pedersen C, Faurschou M, Jacobsen S: The risk of cardiovascular morbidity and cardiovascular mortality in systemic lupus erythematosus and lupus nephritis: A Danish nationwide population-based cohort study. Rheumatology (Oxford) 56: 709–715, 2017
Lee T, Derebail VK, Kshirsagar AV, Chung Y, Fine JP, Mahoney S, Poulton CJ, Lionaki S, Hogan SL, Falk RJ, Cattran DC, Hladunewich M, Reich HN, Nachman PH: Patients with primary membranous nephropathy are at high risk of cardiovascular events. Kidney Int 89: 1111–1118, 2016
Morgan MD, Turnbull J, Selamet U, Kaur-Hayer M, Nightingale P, Ferro CJ, Savage CO, Harper L: Increased incidence of cardiovascular events in patients with antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-associated vasculitides: A matched-pair cohort study. Arthritis Rheum 60: 3493–3500, 2009
Jarrick S, Lundberg S, Welander A, Carrero JJ, Höijer J, Bottai M, Ludvigsson JF: Mortality in IgA nephropathy: A nationwide population-based cohort study. J Am Soc Nephrol 30: 866–876, 2019
Lee H, Kim DK, Oh KH, Joo KW, Kim YS, Chae DW, Kim S, Chin HJ: Mortality and renal outcome of primary glomerulonephritis in Korea: Observation in 1,943 biopsied cases. Am J Nephrol 37: 74–83, 2013
Sim JJ, Bhandari SK, Batech M, Hever A, Harrison TN, Shu YH, Kujubu DA, Jonelis TY, Kanter MH, Jacobsen SJ: End-stage renal disease and mortality outcomes across different glomerulonephropathies in a large diverse US population. Mayo Clin Proc 93: 167–178, 2018
Jefferson JA: Complications of immunosuppression in glomerular disease. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 13: 1264–1275, 2018
Canetta PA, Troost JP, Mahoney S, Kogon AJ, Carlozzi N, Bartosh SM, Cai Y, Davis TK, Fernandez H, Fornoni A, Gbadegesin RA, Herreshoff E, Mahan JD, Nachman PH, Selewski DT, Sethna CB, Srivastava T, Tuttle KR, Wang CS, Falk RJ, Gharavi AG, Gillespie BW, Greenbaum LA, Holzman LB, Kretzler M, Robinson BM, Smoyer WE, Guay-Woodford LM, Reeve B, Gipson DS; CureGN Consortium: Health-related quality of life in glomerular disease. Kidney Int 95: 1209–1224, 2019
de Barros BP, Nishiura JL, Heilberg IP, Kirsztajn GM: Anxiety, depression, and quality of life in patients with familial glomerulonephritis or autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. J Bras Nefrol 33: 120–128, 2011
Gipson DS, Trachtman H, Kaskel FJ, Radeva MK, Gassman J, Greene TH, Moxey-Mims MM, Hogg RJ, Watkins SL, Fine RN, Middleton JP, Vehaskari VM, Hogan SL, Vento S, Flynn PA, Powell LM, McMahan JL, Siegel N, Friedman AL: Clinical trials treating focal segmental glomerulosclerosis should measure patient quality of life. Kidney Int 79: 678–685, 2011
Grootscholten C, Snoek FJ, Bijl M, van Houwelingen HC, Derksen RH, Berden JH; Dutch Working Party of SLE: Health-related quality of life and treatment burden in patients with proliferative lupus nephritis treated with cyclophosphamide or azathioprine/methylprednisolone in a randomized controlled trial. J Rheumatol 34: 1699–1707, 2007
Carter SA, Gutman T, Logeman C, Cattran D, Lightstone L, Bagga A, Barbour SJ, Barratt J, Boletis J, Caster D, Coppo R, Fervenza FC, Floege J, Hladunewich M, Hogan JJ, Kitching AR, Lafayette RA, Malvar A, Radhakrishnan J, Rovin BH, Scholes-Robertson N, Trimarchi H, Zhang H, Azukaitis K, Cho Y, Viecelli AK, Dunn L, Harris D, Johnson DW, Kerr PG, Laboi P, Ryan J, Shen JI, Ruiz L, Wang AY, Lee AHK, Fung S, Tong MK, Teixeira-Pinto A, Wilkie M, Alexander SI, Craig JC, Tong A; SONG-GD Investigators: Identifying outcomes important to patients with glomerular disease and their caregivers. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 15: 673–684, 2020
Baigent C, Herrington WG, Coresh J, Landray MJ, Levin A, Perkovic V, Pfeffer MA, Rossing P, Walsh M, Wanner C, Wheeler DC, Winkelmayer WC, McMurray JJV; KDIGO Controversies Conference on Challenges in the Conduct of Clinical Trials in Nephrology Conference Participants: Challenges in conducting clinical trials in nephrology: Conclusions from a Kidney Disease-Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) Controversies Conference. Kidney Int 92: 297–305, 2017
Banerjee D, Lowe-Jones R, Damster S, Thomas N, Scholes-Robertson N, Tong A, Levin A; ISN-ACT Patient-Engagement in Clinical Trials Group: International perspectives on patient involvement in clinical trials in nephrology. Kidney Int 98: 566–571, 2020
Chen Y, Schieppati A, Chen X, Cai G, Zamora J, Giuliano GA, Braun N, Perna A: Immunosuppressive treatment for idiopathic membranous nephropathy in adults with nephrotic syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014: CD004293, 2014
Vecchio M, Bonerba B, Palmer SC, Craig JC, Ruospo M, Samuels JA, Molony DA, Schena FP, Strippoli GF: Immunosuppressive agents for treating IgA nephropathy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev (8): CD003965, 2015
Walters G, Willis NS, Craig JC: Interventions for renal vasculitis in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev (9): CD003232, 2015
Leaf DE, Appel GB, Radhakrishnan J: Glomerular disease: Why is there a dearth of high quality clinical trials? Kidney Int 78: 337–342, 2010
Carter SA, Lightstone L, Cattran D, Bagga A, Barbour SJ, Barratt J, Boletis J, Caster D, Coppo R, Fervenza FC, Floege J, Hladunewich M, Hogan JJ, Kitching AR, Lafayette R, Malvar A, Radhakrishnan J, Rovin BH, Zhang H, Gutman T, Howell M, Logeman C, Shen JI, Teixeira-Pinto A, Alexander SI, Cho Y, Craig JC, Harris D, Johnson DW, Kerr PG, Ryan J, Viecelli AK, Wang AY, Wilkie M, Scholes-Robertson N, Tong A; SONG-GD Initiative: Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Glomerular Disease (SONG-GD): Establishing a core outcome set for trials in patients with glomerular disease. Kidney Int 95: 1280–1283, 2019
Carter SA, Logeman C, Howell M, Cattran D, Lightstone L, Bagga A, Barbour SJ, Barratt J, Boletis J, Caster DJ, Coppo R, Fervenza FC, Floege J, Hladunewich MA, Hogan JJ, Kitching AR, Lafayette RA, Malvar A, Radhakrishnan J, Rovin BH, Scholes-Robertson N, Trimarchi H, Zhang H, Cho Y, Dunn L, Gipson DS, Liew A, Sautenet B, Viecelli AK, Harris D, Johnson DW, Wang AY, Teixeira-Pinto A, Alexander SI, Martin A, Tong A, Craig JC: Development of an international Delphi survey to establish core outcome domains for trials in adults with glomerular disease. Kidney Int 100: 881–893, 2021
SONG Initiative: The SONG Handbook, Version 1, Sydney, Australia, SONG Initiative, 2017. Available at: songinitiative.org/reports-and-publications/ . Accessed January 1, 2019
Williamson PR, Altman DG, Bagley H, Barnes KL, Blazeby JM, Brookes ST, Clarke M, Gargon E, Gorst S, Harman N, Kirkham JJ, McNair A, Prinsen CAC, Schmitt J, Terwee CB, Young B: The COMET Handbook, Version 1.0. Trials 18: 280, 2017
Levin A, Agarwal R, Herrington WG, Heerspink HL, Mann JFE, Shahinfar S, Tuttle KR, Donner JA, Jha V, Nangaku M, de Zeeuw D, Jardine MJ, Mahaffey KW, Thompson AM, Beaucage M, Chong K, Roberts GV, Sunwold D, Vorster H, Warren M, Damster S, Malik C, Perkovic V; participant authors of the International Society of Nephrology’s 1st International Consensus Meeting on Defining Kidney Failure in Clinical Trials: International consensus definitions of clinical trial outcomes for kidney failure: 2020. Kidney Int 98: 849–859, 2020
Cattran DC, Kim ED, Reich H, Hladunewich M, Kim SJ; Toronto Glomerulonephritis Registry group: Membranous nephropathy: Quantifying remission duration on outcome. J Am Soc Nephrol 28: 995–1003, 2017
Pakchotanon R, Gladman DD, Su J, Urowitz MB: Sustained complete renal remission is a predictor of reduced mortality, chronic kidney disease and end-stage renal disease in lupus nephritis. Lupus 27: 468–474, 2018
Levey AS, Gansevoort RT, Coresh J, Inker LA, Heerspink HL, Grams ME, Greene T, Tighiouart H, Matsushita K, Ballew SH, Sang Y, Vonesh E, Ying J, Manley T, de Zeeuw D, Eckardt KU, Levin A, Perkovic V, Zhang L, Willis K: Change in albuminuria and GFR as end points for clinical trials in early stages of CKD: A scientific workshop sponsored by the National Kidney Foundation in collaboration with the US Food and Drug Administration and European Medicines Agency. Am J Kidney Dis 75: 84–104, 2020
Manera KE, Johnson DW, Craig JC, Shen JI, Gutman T, Cho Y, Wang AY, Brown EA, Brunier G, Dong J, Dunning T, Mehrotra R, Naicker S, Pecoits-Filho R, Perl J, Wilkie M, Tong A; SONG-PD Workshop Investigators: Establishing a core outcome set for peritoneal dialysis: Report of the SONG-PD (Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Peritoneal Dialysis) Consensus Workshop. Am J Kidney Dis 75: 404–412, 2020
Tong A, Gill J, Budde K, Marson L, Reese PP, Rosenbloom D, Rostaing L, Wong G, Josephson MA, Pruett TL, Warrens AN, Craig JC, Sautenet B, Evangelidis N, Ralph AF, Hanson CS, Shen JI, Howard K, Meyer K, Perrone RD, Weiner DE, Fung S, Ma MKM, Rose C, Ryan J, Chen LX, Howell M, Larkins N, Kim S, Thangaraju S, Ju A, Chapman JR; SONG-Tx Investigators: Toward establishing core outcome domains for trials in kidney transplantation: Report of the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Kidney Transplantation Consensus Workshops. Transplantation 101: 1887–1896, 2017
Hanson CS, Craig JC, Logeman C, Sinha A, Dart A, Eddy AA, Guha C, Gipson DS, Bockenhauer D, Yap HK, Groothoff J, Zappitelli M, Webb NJA, Alexander SI, Furth SL, Samuel S, Neu A, Viecelli AK, Ju A, Sharma A, Au EH, Desmond H, Shen JI, Manera KE, Azukaitis K, Dunn L, Carter SA, Gutman T, Cho Y, Walker A, Francis A, Sanchez-Kazi C, Kausman J, Pearl M, Benador N, Sahney S, Tong A; SONG-Kids consensus workshops investigators: Establishing core outcome domains in pediatric kidney disease: report of the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Children and Adolescents (SONG-KIDS) consensus workshops. Kidney Int 98: 553–565, 2020
Tong A, Manns B, Hemmelgarn B, Wheeler DC, Evangelidis N, Tugwell P, Crowe S, Van Biesen W, Winkelmayer WC, O’Donoghue D, Tam-Tham H, Shen JI, Pinter J, Larkins N, Youssouf S, Mandayam S, Ju A, Craig JC; SONG-HD Investigators: Establishing core outcome domains in hemodialysis: Report of the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Hemodialysis (SONG-HD) Consensus Workshop. Am J Kidney Dis 69: 97–107, 2017
Cho Y, Tong A, Craig JC, Mustafa RA, Chapman A, Perrone RD, Ahn C, Fowler K, Torres V, Gansevoort RT, Ong ACM, Coolican H, Tze-Wah Kao J, Harris T, Gutman T, Shen JI, Viecelli AK, Johnson DW, Au E, El-Damanawi R, Logeman C, Ju A, Manera KE, Chonchol M, Odland D, Baron D, Pei Y, Sautenet B, Rastogi A, Sharma A, Rangan G; SONG-PKD Workshop Investigators: Establishing a core outcome set for autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease: Report of the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology-Polycystic Kidney Disease (SONG-PKD) Consensus Workshop. Am J Kidney Dis 77: 255–263, 2021
Go AS, Chertow GM, Fan D, McCulloch CE, Hsu CY: Chronic kidney disease and the risks of death, cardiovascular events, and hospitalization. N Engl J Med 351: 1296–1305, 2004
Hutton HL, Levin A, Gill J, Djurdjev O, Tang M, Barbour SJ: Cardiovascular risk is similar in patients with glomerulonephritis compared to other types of chronic kidney disease: A matched cohort study. BMC Nephrol 18: 95, 2017
Boers M, Kirwan JR, Wells G, Beaton D, Gossec L, d’Agostino MA, Conaghan PG, Bingham CO 3rd, Brooks P, Landewé R, March L, Simon LS, Singh JA, Strand V, Tugwell P: Developing core outcome measurement sets for clinical trials: OMERACT filter 2.0. J Clin Epidemiol 67: 745–753, 2014