Limitation of life-sustaining therapies in critically ill patients with COVID-19: a descriptive epidemiological investigation from the COVID-ICU study.
Acute respiratory distress syndrome
COVID-19
Critical care
Ethical
Life-sustaining therapy
Outcome
Journal
Critical care (London, England)
ISSN: 1466-609X
Titre abrégé: Crit Care
Pays: England
ID NLM: 9801902
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
11 03 2023
11 03 2023
Historique:
received:
31
10
2022
accepted:
06
02
2023
entrez:
11
3
2023
pubmed:
13
3
2023
medline:
15
3
2023
Statut:
epublish
Résumé
Limitations of life-sustaining therapies (LST) practices are frequent and vary among intensive care units (ICUs). However, scarce data were available during the COVID-19 pandemic when ICUs were under intense pressure. We aimed to investigate the prevalence, cumulative incidence, timing, modalities, and factors associated with LST decisions in critically ill COVID-19 patients. We did an ancillary analysis of the European multicentre COVID-ICU study, which collected data from 163 ICUs in France, Belgium and Switzerland. ICU load, a parameter reflecting stress on ICU capacities, was calculated at the patient level using daily ICU bed occupancy data from official country epidemiological reports. Mixed effects logistic regression was used to assess the association of variables with LST limitation decisions. Among 4671 severe COVID-19 patients admitted from February 25 to May 4, 2020, the prevalence of in-ICU LST limitations was 14.5%, with a nearly six-fold variability between centres. Overall 28-day cumulative incidence of LST limitations was 12.4%, which occurred at a median of 8 days (3-21). Median ICU load at the patient level was 126%. Age, clinical frailty scale score, and respiratory severity were associated with LST limitations, while ICU load was not. In-ICU death occurred in 74% and 95% of patients, respectively, after LST withholding and withdrawal, while median survival time was 3 days (1-11) after LST limitations. In this study, LST limitations frequently preceded death, with a major impact on time of death. In contrast to ICU load, older age, frailty, and the severity of respiratory failure during the first 24 h were the main factors associated with decisions of LST limitations.
Sections du résumé
BACKGROUND
Limitations of life-sustaining therapies (LST) practices are frequent and vary among intensive care units (ICUs). However, scarce data were available during the COVID-19 pandemic when ICUs were under intense pressure. We aimed to investigate the prevalence, cumulative incidence, timing, modalities, and factors associated with LST decisions in critically ill COVID-19 patients.
METHODS
We did an ancillary analysis of the European multicentre COVID-ICU study, which collected data from 163 ICUs in France, Belgium and Switzerland. ICU load, a parameter reflecting stress on ICU capacities, was calculated at the patient level using daily ICU bed occupancy data from official country epidemiological reports. Mixed effects logistic regression was used to assess the association of variables with LST limitation decisions.
RESULTS
Among 4671 severe COVID-19 patients admitted from February 25 to May 4, 2020, the prevalence of in-ICU LST limitations was 14.5%, with a nearly six-fold variability between centres. Overall 28-day cumulative incidence of LST limitations was 12.4%, which occurred at a median of 8 days (3-21). Median ICU load at the patient level was 126%. Age, clinical frailty scale score, and respiratory severity were associated with LST limitations, while ICU load was not. In-ICU death occurred in 74% and 95% of patients, respectively, after LST withholding and withdrawal, while median survival time was 3 days (1-11) after LST limitations.
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, LST limitations frequently preceded death, with a major impact on time of death. In contrast to ICU load, older age, frailty, and the severity of respiratory failure during the first 24 h were the main factors associated with decisions of LST limitations.
Identifiants
pubmed: 36906643
doi: 10.1186/s13054-023-04349-1
pii: 10.1186/s13054-023-04349-1
pmc: PMC10006561
doi:
Types de publication
Journal Article
Langues
eng
Sous-ensembles de citation
IM
Pagination
103Investigateurs
Alain Mercat
(A)
Pierre Asfar
(P)
François Beloncle
(F)
Julien Demiselle
(J)
Tài Pham
(T)
Arthur Pavot
(A)
Xavier Monnet
(X)
Christian Richard
(C)
Alexandre Demoule
(A)
Martin Dres
(M)
Julien Mayaux
(J)
Alexandra Beurton
(A)
Cédric Daubin
(C)
Richard Descamps
(R)
Aurélie Joret
(A)
Damien Du Cheyron
(D)
Frédéric Pene
(F)
Jean-Daniel Chiche
(JD)
Mathieu Jozwiak
(M)
Paul Jaubert
(P)
Guillaume Voiriot
(G)
Muriel Fartoukh
(M)
Marion Teulier
(M)
Clarisse Blayau
(C)
Erwen L'Her
(E)
Cécile Aubron
(C)
Laetitia Bodenes
(L)
Nicolas Ferriere
(N)
Johann Auchabie
(J)
Anthony Le Meur
(A)
Sylvain Pignal
(S)
Thierry Mazzoni
(T)
Jean-Pierre Quenot
(JP)
Pascal Andreu
(P)
Jean-Baptiste Roudau
(JB)
Marie Labruyère
(M)
Saad Nseir
(S)
Sébastien Preau
(S)
Julien Poissy
(J)
Daniel Mathieu
(D)
Sarah Benhamida
(S)
Rémi Paulet
(R)
Nicolas Roucaud
(N)
Martial Thyrault
(M)
Florence Daviet
(F)
Sami Hraiech
(S)
Gabriel Parzy
(G)
Aude Sylvestre
(A)
Sébastien Jochmans
(S)
Anne-Laure Bouilland
(AL)
Mehran Monchi
(M)
Marc Danguy des Déserts
(MDD)
Quentin Mathais
(Q)
Gwendoline Rager
(G)
Pierre Pasquier
(P)
Jean Reignier
(J)
Amélie Seguin
(A)
Charlotte Garret
(C)
Emmanuel Canet
(E)
Jean Dellamonica
(J)
Clément Saccheri
(C)
Romain Lombardi
(R)
Yanis Kouchit
(Y)
Sophie Jacquier
(S)
Armelle Mathonnet
(A)
Mai-Ahn Nay
(MA)
Isabelle Runge
(I)
Frédéric Martino
(F)
Laure Flurin
(L)
Amélie Rolle
(A)
Michel Carles
(M)
Rémi Coudroy
(R)
Arnaud W Thille
(AW)
Jean-Pierre Frat
(JP)
Maeva Rodriguez
(M)
Pascal Beuret
(P)
Audrey Tientcheu
(A)
Arthur Vincent
(A)
Florian Michelin
(F)
Fabienne Tamion
(F)
Dorothée Carpentier
(D)
Déborah Boyer
(D)
Gaetan Beduneau
(G)
Valérie Gissot
(V)
Stéphan Ehrmann
(S)
Charlotte Salmon Gandonniere
(CS)
Djlali Elaroussi
(D)
Agathe Delbove
(A)
Yannick Fedun
(Y)
Julien Huntzinger
(J)
Eddy Lebas
(E)
Grâce Kisoka
(G)
Céline Grégoire
(C)
Stella Marchetta
(S)
Bernard Lambermont
(B)
Laurent Argaud
(L)
Thomas Baudry
(T)
Pierre-Jean Bertrand
(PJ)
Auguste Dargent
(A)
Christophe Guitton
(C)
Nicolas Chudeau
(N)
Mickaël Landais
(M)
Cédric Darreau
(C)
Alexis Ferre
(A)
Antoine Gros
(A)
Guillaume Lacave
(G)
Fabrice Bruneel
(F)
Mathilde Neuville
(M)
Jérôme Devaquet
(J)
Guillaume Tachon
(G)
Richard Gallot
(R)
Riad Chelha
(R)
Arnaud Galbois
(A)
Anne Jallot
(A)
Ludivine Chalumeau Lemoine
(LC)
Khaldoun Kuteifan
(K)
Valentin Pointurier
(V)
Louise-Marie Jandeaux
(LM)
Joy Mootien
(J)
Charles Damoisel
(C)
Benjamin Sztrymf
(B)
Matthieu Schmidt
(M)
Alain Combes
(A)
Juliette Chommeloux
(J)
Charles Edouard Luyt
(CE)
Frédérique Schortgen
(F)
Leon Rusel
(L)
Camille Jung
(C)
Florent Gobert
(F)
Damien Vimpere
(D)
Lionel Lamhaut
(L)
Bertrand Sauneuf
(B)
Liliane Charrrier
(L)
Julien Calus
(J)
Isabelle Desmeules
(I)
Benoît Painvin
(B)
Jean-Marc Tadie
(JM)
Vincent Castelain
(V)
Baptiste Michard
(B)
Jean-Etienne Herbrecht
(JE)
Mathieu Baldacini
(M)
Vincent Castelain
(V)
Baptiste Michard
(B)
Jean-Etienne Herbrecht
(JE)
Mathieu Baldacini
(M)
Nicolas Weiss
(N)
Sophie Demeret
(S)
Clémence Marois
(C)
Benjamin Rohaut
(B)
Pierre-Henri Moury
(PH)
Anne-Charlotte Savida
(AC)
Emmanuel Couadau
(E)
Mathieu Série
(M)
Nica Alexandru
(N)
Cédric Bruel
(C)
Candice Fontaine
(C)
Sonia Garrigou
(S)
Juliette Courtiade Mahler
(JC)
Maxime Leclerc
(M)
Michel Ramakers
(M)
Pierre Garçon
(P)
Nicole Massou
(N)
Ly Van Vong
(L)
Juliane Sen
(J)
Nolwenn Lucas
(N)
Franck Chemouni
(F)
Annabelle Stoclin
(A)
Alexandre Avenel
(A)
Henri Faure
(H)
Angélie Gentilhomme
(A)
Sylvie Ricome
(S)
Paul Abraham
(P)
Céline Monard
(C)
Julien Textoris
(J)
Thomas Rimmele
(T)
Florent Montini
(F)
Gabriel Lejour
(G)
Thierry Lazard
(T)
Isabelle Etienney
(I)
Younes Kerroumi
(Y)
Claire Dupuis
(C)
Marine Bereiziat
(M)
Elisabeth Coupez
(E)
François Thouy
(F)
Clément Hoffmann
(C)
Nicolas Donat
(N)
Anne Chrisment
(A)
Rose-Marie Blot
(RM)
Antoine Kimmoun
(A)
Audrey Jacquot
(A)
Matthieu Mattei
(M)
Bruno Levy
(B)
Ramin Ravan
(R)
Loïc Dopeux
(L)
Jean-Mathias Liteaudon
(JM)
Delphine Roux
(D)
Brice Rey
(B)
Radu Anghel
(R)
Deborah Schenesse
(D)
Vincent Gevrey
(V)
Jermy Castanera
(J)
Philippe Petua
(P)
Benjamin Madeux
(B)
Otto Hartman
(O)
Michael Piagnerelli
(M)
Anne Joosten
(A)
Cinderella Noel
(C)
Patrick Biston
(P)
Thibaut Noel
(T)
Gurvan L E Bouar
(GLE)
Messabi Boukhanza
(M)
Elsa Demarest
(E)
Marie-France Bajolet
(MF)
Nathanaël Charrier
(N)
Audrey Quenet
(A)
Cécile Zylberfajn
(C)
Nicolas Dufour
(N)
Buno Mégarbane
(B)
Sébastian Voicu
(S)
Nicolas Deye
(N)
Isabelle Malissin
(I)
François Legay
(F)
Matthieu Debarre
(M)
Nicolas Barbarot
(N)
Pierre Fillatre
(P)
Bertrand Delord
(B)
Thomas Laterrade
(T)
Tahar Saghi
(T)
Wilfried Pujol
(W)
Pierre Julien Cungi
(PJ)
Pierre Esnault
(P)
Mickael Cardinale
(M)
Vivien Hong Tuan Ha
(VHT)
Grégory Fleury
(G)
Marie-Ange Brou
(MA)
Daniel Zafimahazo
(D)
David Tran-Van
(D)
Patrick Avargues
(P)
Lisa Carenco
(L)
Nicolas Robin
(N)
Alexandre Ouali
(A)
Lucie Houdou
(L)
Christophe Le Terrier
(C)
Noémie Suh
(N)
Steve Primmaz
(S)
Jérome Pugin
(J)
Emmanuel Weiss
(E)
Tobias Gauss
(T)
Jean-Denis Moyer
(JD)
Catherine Paugam Burtz
(CP)
Béatrice La Combe
(B)
Rolland Smonig
(R)
Jade Violleau
(J)
Pauline Cailliez
(P)
Jonathan Chelly
(J)
Antoine Marchalot
(A)
Cécile Saladin
(C)
Christelle Bigot
(C)
Pierre-Marie Fayolle
(PM)
Jules Fatséas
(J)
Amr Ibrahim
(A)
Dabor Resiere
(D)
Rabih Hage
(R)
Clémentine Cholet
(C)
Marie Cantier
(M)
Pierre Trouiler
(P)
Philippe Montravers
(P)
Brice Lortat-Jacob
(B)
Sebastien Tanaka
(S)
Alexy Tran Dinh
(AT)
Jacques Duranteau
(J)
Anatole Harrois
(A)
Guillaume Dubreuil
(G)
Marie Werner
(M)
Anne Godier
(A)
Sophie Hamada
(S)
Diane Zlotnik
(D)
Hélène Nougue
(H)
Armand Mekontso-Dessap
(A)
Guillaume Carteaux
(G)
Keyvan Razazi
(K)
Nicolas De Prost
(N)
Nicolas Mongardon
(N)
Meriam Lamraoui
(M)
Claire Alessandri
(C)
Quentin de Roux
(Q)
Charles de Roquetaillade
(C)
Benjamin G Chousterman
(BG)
Alexandre Mebazaa
(A)
Etienne Gayat
(E)
Marc Garnier
(M)
Emmanuel Pardo
(E)
Lea Satre-Buisson
(L)
Christophe Gutton
(C)
Elise Yvin
(E)
Clémence Marcault
(C)
Elie Azoulay
(E)
Michael Darmon
(M)
Hafid Ait Oufella
(HA)
Geoffroy Hariri
(G)
Tomas Urbina
(T)
Sandie Mazerand
(S)
Nicholas Heming
(N)
Francesca Santi
(F)
Pierre Moine
(P)
Djillali Annane
(D)
Adrien Bouglé
(A)
Edris Omar
(E)
Aymeric Lancelot
(A)
Emmanuelle Begot
(E)
Gaétan Plantefeve
(G)
Damien Contou
(D)
Hervé Mentec
(H)
Olivier Pajot
(O)
Stanislas Faguer
(S)
Olivier Cointault
(O)
Laurence Lavayssiere
(L)
Marie-Béatrice Nogier
(MB)
Matthieu Jamme
(M)
Claire Pichereau
(C)
Jan Hayon
(J)
Hervé Outin
(H)
François Dépret
(F)
Maxime Coutrot
(M)
Maité Chaussard
(M)
Lucie Guillemet
(L)
Pierre Goffin
(P)
Romain Thouny
(R)
Julien Guntz
(J)
Laurent Jadot
(L)
Romain Persichini
(R)
Vanessa Jean-Michel
(V)
Hugues Georges
(H)
Thomas Caulier
(T)
Gaël Pradel
(G)
Marie-Hélène Hausermann
(MH)
Thi My Hue Nguyen-Valat
(TMH)
Michel Boudinaud
(M)
Emmanuel Vivier
(E)
Sylvène Rosseli
(S)
Gaël Bourdin
(G)
Christian Pommier
(C)
Marc Vinclair
(M)
Simon Poignant
(S)
Sandrine Mons
(S)
Wulfran Bougouin
(W)
Franklin Bruna
(F)
Quentin Maestraggi
(Q)
Christian Roth
(C)
Laurent Bitker
(L)
François Dhelft
(F)
Justine Bonnet-Chateau
(J)
Mathilde Filippelli
(M)
Tristan Morichau-Beauchant
(T)
Stéphane Thierry
(S)
Charlotte Le Roy
(C)
Mélanie Saint Jouan
(MS)
Bruno Goncalves
(B)
Aurélien Mazeraud
(A)
Matthieu Daniel
(M)
Tarek Sharshar
(T)
Cyril Cadoz
(C)
Rostane Gaci
(R)
Sébastien Gette
(S)
Guillaune Louis
(G)
Sophe-Caroline Sacleux
(SC)
Marie-Amélie Ordan
(MA)
Aurélie Cravoisy
(A)
Marie Conrad
(M)
Guilhem Courte
(G)
Sébastien Gibot
(S)
Younès Benzidi
(Y)
Claudia Casella
(C)
Laurent Serpin
(L)
Jean-Lou Setti
(JL)
Marie-Catherine Besse
(MC)
Anna Bourreau
(A)
Jérôme Pillot
(J)
Caroline Rivera
(C)
Camille Vinclair
(C)
Marie-Aline Robaux
(MA)
Chloé Achino
(C)
Marie-Charlotte Delignette
(MC)
Tessa Mazard
(T)
Frédéric Aubrun
(F)
Bruno Bouchet
(B)
Aurélien Frérou
(A)
Laura Muller
(L)
Charlotte Quentin
(C)
Samuel Degoul
(S)
Xavier Stihle
(X)
Claude Sumian
(C)
Nicoletta Bergero
(N)
Bernard Lanaspre
(B)
Hervé Quintard
(H)
Eve Marie Maiziere
(EM)
Pierre-Yves Egreteau
(PY)
Guillaume Leloup
(G)
Florin Berteau
(F)
Marjolaine Cottrel
(M)
Marie Bouteloup
(M)
Matthieu Jeannot
(M)
Quentin Blanc
(Q)
Julien Saison
(J)
Isabelle Geneau
(I)
Romaric Grenot
(R)
Abdel Ouchike
(A)
Pascal Hazera
(P)
Anne-Lyse Masse
(AL)
Suela Demiri
(S)
Corinne Vezinet
(C)
Elodie Baron
(E)
Deborah Benchetrit
(D)
Antoine Monsel
(A)
Grégoire Trebbia
(G)
Emmanuelle Schaack
(E)
Raphaël Lepecq
(R)
Mathieu Bobet
(M)
Christophe Vinsonneau
(C)
Thibault Dekeyser
(T)
Quentin Delforge
(Q)
Imen Rahmani
(I)
Bérengère Vivet
(B)
Jonathan Paillot
(J)
Lucie Hierle
(L)
Claire Chaignat
(C)
Sarah Valette
(S)
Benoït Her
(B)
Jennifier Brunet
(J)
Mathieu Page
(M)
Fabienne Boiste
(F)
Anthony Collin
(A)
Florent Bavozet
(F)
Aude Garin
(A)
Mohamed Dlala
(M)
Kais Mhamdi
(K)
Bassem Beilouny
(B)
Alexandra Lavalard
(A)
Severine Perez
(S)
Benoit Veber
(B)
Pierre-Gildas Guitard
(PG)
Philippe Gouin
(P)
Anna Lamacz
(A)
Fabienne Plouvier
(F)
Bertrand P Delaborde
(BP)
Aïssa Kherchache
(A)
Amina Chaalal
(A)
Jean-Damien Ricard
(JD)
Marc Amouretti
(M)
Santiago Freita-Ramos
(S)
Damien Roux
(D)
Jean-Michel Constantin
(JM)
Mona Assefi
(M)
Marine Lecore
(M)
Agathe Selves
(A)
Florian Prevost
(F)
Christian Lamer
(C)
Ruiying Shi
(R)
Lyes Knani
(L)
Sébastien Pili Floury
(SP)
Lucie Vettoretti
(L)
Michael Levy
(M)
Lucile Marsac
(L)
Stéphane Dauger
(S)
Sophie Guilmin-Crépon
(S)
Hadrien Winiszewski
(H)
Gael Piton
(G)
Thibaud Soumagne
(T)
Gilles Capellier
(G)
Jean-Baptiste Putegnat
(JB)
Frédérique Bayle
(F)
Maya Perrou
(M)
Ghyslaine Thao
(G)
Guillaume Géri
(G)
Cyril Charron
(C)
Xavier Repessé
(X)
Antoine Vieillard-Baron
(A)
Mathieu Guilbart
(M)
Pierre-Alexandre Roger
(PA)
Sébastien Hinard
(S)
Pierre-Yves Macq
(PY)
Kevin Chaulier
(K)
Sylvie Goutte
(S)
Patrick Chillet
(P)
Anaïs Pitta
(A)
Barbara Darjent
(B)
Amandine Bruneau
(A)
Sigismond Lasocki
(S)
Maxime Leger
(M)
Soizic Gergaud
(S)
Pierre Lemarie
(P)
Nicolas Terzi
(N)
Carole Schwebel
(C)
Anaïs Dartevel
(A)
Louis-Marie Galerneau
(LM)
Jean-Luc Diehl
(JL)
Caroline Hauw-Berlemont
(C)
Nicolas Péron
(N)
Emmanuel Guérot
(E)
Abolfazl Mohebbi Amoli
(AM)
Michel Benhamou
(M)
Jean-Pierre Deyme
(JP)
Olivier Andremont
(O)
Diane Lena
(D)
Julien Cady
(J)
Arnaud Causeret
(A)
Arnaud De La Chapelle
(A)
Christophe Cracco
(C)
Stéphane Rouleau
(S)
David Schnell
(D)
Camille Foucault
(C)
Cécile Lory
(C)
Thibault Chapelle
(T)
Vincent Bruckert
(V)
Julie Garcia
(J)
Abdlazize Sahraoui
(A)
Nathalie Abbosh
(N)
Caroline Bornstain
(C)
Pierre Pernet
(P)
Florent Poirson
(F)
Ahmed Pasem
(A)
Philippe Karoubi
(P)
Virginie Poupinel
(V)
Caroline Gauthier
(C)
François Bouniol
(F)
Philippe Feuchere
(P)
Florent Bavozet
(F)
Anne Heron
(A)
Serge Carreira
(S)
Malo Emery
(M)
Anne Sophie Le Floch
(AS)
Luana Giovannangeli
(L)
Nicolas Herzog
(N)
Christophe Giacardi
(C)
Thibaut Baudic
(T)
Chloé Thill
(C)
Said Lebbah
(S)
Jessica Palmyre
(J)
Florence Tubach
(F)
David Hajage
(D)
Nicolas Bonnet
(N)
Nathan Ebstein
(N)
Stéphane Gaudry
(S)
Yves Cohen
(Y)
Julie Noublanche
(J)
Olivier Lesieur
(O)
Arnaud Sément
(A)
Isabel Roca-Cerezo
(I)
Michel Pascal
(M)
Nesrine Sma
(N)
Gwenhaël Colin
(G)
Jean-Claude Lacherade
(JC)
Gauthier Bionz
(G)
Natacha Maquigneau
(N)
Pierre Bouzat
(P)
Michel Durand
(M)
Marie-Christine Hérault
(MC)
Jean-Francois Payen
(JF)
Commentaires et corrections
Type : CommentIn
Informations de copyright
© 2023. The Author(s).
Références
J Crit Care. 2022 Feb;67:147-148
pubmed: 34781100
Crit Care Med. 2015 Aug;43(8):1587-94
pubmed: 25867907
Anesthesiology. 2017 May;126(5):882-889
pubmed: 28296682
Intensive Care Med. 2015 Oct;41(10):1763-72
pubmed: 26149302
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2013 Oct 1;188(7):800-6
pubmed: 23992449
BMC Med. 2021 Aug 30;19(1):213
pubmed: 34461893
JAMA Netw Open. 2021 Jan 4;4(1):e2034266
pubmed: 33464319
Chest. 2014 Sep;146(3):573-582
pubmed: 24522751
Intensive Care Med. 2021 Jan;47(1):119-121
pubmed: 33021683
Intensive Care Med. 1996 Jul;22(7):707-10
pubmed: 8844239
JAMA. 2020 Jun 16;323(23):2367-2368
pubmed: 32412580
Lancet. 2007 Oct 20;370(9596):1453-7
pubmed: 18064739
Crit Care. 2021 Sep 23;25(1):344
pubmed: 34556171
Intensive Care Med. 2018 Jul;44(7):1027-1038
pubmed: 29774388
Ann Intensive Care. 2021 Aug 19;11(1):127
pubmed: 34410543
Intensive Care Med. 2022 Jan;48(1):124-125
pubmed: 34741189
Intensive Care Med. 2015 Sep;41(9):1572-85
pubmed: 25904183
Res Synth Methods. 2010 Apr;1(2):97-111
pubmed: 26061376
Intensive Care Med. 2021 Jan;47(1):60-73
pubmed: 33211135
Intensive Care Med. 2022 Apr;48(4):435-447
pubmed: 35218366
Lancet Respir Med. 2021 Oct;9(10):1101-1110
pubmed: 34364537
Intensive Care Med. 2016 Jun;42(6):987-94
pubmed: 26862018
Intensive Care Med. 2005 Jun;31(6):823-31
pubmed: 15856168
JAMA. 2003 Aug 13;290(6):790-7
pubmed: 12915432
Intensive Care Med. 2020 Sep;46(9):1779-1780
pubmed: 32572526
JAMA. 1993 Dec 22-29;270(24):2957-63
pubmed: 8254858
Can Geriatr J. 2016 Jun 29;19(2):34-9
pubmed: 27403211
JAMA. 2020 May 12;323(18):1773-1774
pubmed: 32219367
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2018 Jan 15;197(2):263-266
pubmed: 28650201