Systematic review of clinical practice guidelines for traumatic dental injuries.
AGREE II
clinical practices
dental trauma
guideline
recommendations
traumatic dental injuries
Journal
Dental traumatology : official publication of International Association for Dental Traumatology
ISSN: 1600-9657
Titre abrégé: Dent Traumatol
Pays: Denmark
ID NLM: 101091305
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
Aug 2023
Aug 2023
Historique:
revised:
04
03
2023
received:
29
07
2022
accepted:
07
03
2023
medline:
13
7
2023
pubmed:
16
3
2023
entrez:
15
3
2023
Statut:
ppublish
Résumé
Traumatic dental injuries (TDI) are considered a public health problem due to their high prevalence and associated physical, economic, psychological and social consequences. Hence, good Clinical Practice Guidelines are essential to achieving a favourable prognosis. The aim of this review was to appraise the existing Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) on TDI using AGREE II and AGREE-REX. A systematic search for existing guidelines on TDI was performed on PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, ProQuest, National Institute for Health Care Excellence, BMJ Best Practice, Trip database, Guideline International Network, Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, World Health Organisation, Web of Science and 'Ministry of Health worldwide' databases. Four appraisers independently appraised the included CPGs. The AGREE II tool was applied to assess the methodological quality, while AGREE REX assessed the quality of recommendations of the included guidelines. Of the 7736 titles screened, three guidelines, namely the International Association of Dental Traumatology Guidelines (IADT), and the Italian and Malaysian guidelines, were included for the final analysis. These guidelines were published between 2019 and 2020. The AGREE II analysis demonstrated scores above 80% for the IADT and Italian guidelines for the scope and purpose domain. Overall, the Malaysian guidelines achieved the highest score for all domains. The AGREE REX analysis indicated variability in implementation across the nine items, with five that scored above the midpoint of 4.0 on the response scale. Both the Italian and the IADT guidelines had a similar score for the values and preference domains (36.36%). Several deficiencies exist in the methodological quality of existing CPGs on TDI. Future guidelines should consider improvements for domains such as 'rigour of development', 'stakeholder involvement' and 'applicability' to overcome the existing limitations.
Sections du résumé
BACKGROUND/AIMS
OBJECTIVE
Traumatic dental injuries (TDI) are considered a public health problem due to their high prevalence and associated physical, economic, psychological and social consequences. Hence, good Clinical Practice Guidelines are essential to achieving a favourable prognosis. The aim of this review was to appraise the existing Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) on TDI using AGREE II and AGREE-REX.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
METHODS
A systematic search for existing guidelines on TDI was performed on PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, ProQuest, National Institute for Health Care Excellence, BMJ Best Practice, Trip database, Guideline International Network, Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, World Health Organisation, Web of Science and 'Ministry of Health worldwide' databases. Four appraisers independently appraised the included CPGs. The AGREE II tool was applied to assess the methodological quality, while AGREE REX assessed the quality of recommendations of the included guidelines.
RESULTS
RESULTS
Of the 7736 titles screened, three guidelines, namely the International Association of Dental Traumatology Guidelines (IADT), and the Italian and Malaysian guidelines, were included for the final analysis. These guidelines were published between 2019 and 2020. The AGREE II analysis demonstrated scores above 80% for the IADT and Italian guidelines for the scope and purpose domain. Overall, the Malaysian guidelines achieved the highest score for all domains. The AGREE REX analysis indicated variability in implementation across the nine items, with five that scored above the midpoint of 4.0 on the response scale. Both the Italian and the IADT guidelines had a similar score for the values and preference domains (36.36%).
CONCLUSIONS
CONCLUSIONS
Several deficiencies exist in the methodological quality of existing CPGs on TDI. Future guidelines should consider improvements for domains such as 'rigour of development', 'stakeholder involvement' and 'applicability' to overcome the existing limitations.
Types de publication
Systematic Review
Journal Article
Langues
eng
Pagination
371-380Informations de copyright
© 2023 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Références
Chadwick BL, White DA, Morris AJ, Evans D, Pitts NB. Non-carious tooth conditions in children in the UK, 2003. Br Dent J. 2006;200:379-84.
Hamilton FA, Hill FJ, Holloway PJ. An investigation of dento-alveolar trauma and its treatment in an adolescent population. Part 1: the prevalence and incidence of injuries and the extent and adequacy of treatment received. Br Dent J. 1997;182:91-5.
Petersson EE, Andersson L, Sorensen S. Traumatic oral vs non-oral injuries. Swed Dent J. 1997;21:55-68.
Sleet DA. The global challenge of child injury prevention. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2018;15:1921.
Glendor U. Epidemiology of traumatic dental injuries - a 12 year review of the literature. Dent Traumatol. 2008;24:603-11.
Kramer PF, Zembruski C, Ferreira SH, Feldens CA. Traumatic dental injuries in Brazilian preschool children. Dent Traumatol. 2003;19:299-303.
Eyuboglu O, Yilmaz Y, Zehir C, Sahin H. A 6-year investigation into types of dental trauma treated in a paediatric dentistry clinic in eastern Anatolia region. Turkey Dent Traumatol. 2009;25:110-4.
Al-Jundi SH. Dental emergencies presenting to a dental teaching hospital due to complications from traumatic dental injuries. Dent Traumatol. 2002;18:181-5.
Hargreaves JA, Cleaton-Jones PE, Roberts GJ, Williams S, Matejka JM. Trauma to primary teeth of south African pre- school children. Endod Dent Traumatol. 1999;15:73-6.
Borssén E, Holm AK. Treatment of traumatic dental injuries in a cohort of 16-year-olds in northern Sweden. Endod Dent Traumatol. 2000;16:276-81.
Committee to Advise the Public Health Service on Clinical Practice Guidelines, Institute of Medicine, Field MJ, Lohr KN. Clinical practice guidelines: directions of a new program. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1990.
Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Standards for Developing Trustworthy Clinical Practice Guidelines. Clinical practice guidelines we can trust. Washington, DC: National Academies Press (US); 2011.
Field MJ, Lohr KN, editors. Guidelines for clinical practice: from development to use. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1992.
Shekelle PG, Woolf SH, Eccles M, Grimshaw J. Clinical guidelines: developing guidelines. BMJ. 1999;318:593-6.
Hurwitz B. Legal and political considerations of clinical practice guidelines. BMJ. 1999;318:661-4.
Feder G. Management of mild hypertension: which guidelines to follow? BMJ. 1994;308:470-1.
Arieta-Miranda J, Alcaychahua AS, Santos GP, Sevillano MC, Verástegui RL, Victorio DB, et al. Quality assessment of clinical practice guidelines for the management of paediatric dental emergencies applicable to the COVID-19 pandemic, using the AGREE II instrument. A systematic review. Heliyon. 2020;6:e05612.
Tejani T, Mubeen S, Seehra J, Cobourne MT. An exploratory quality assessment of orthodontic clinical guidelines using the AGREE II instrument. Eur J Orthod. 2017;39:654-9.
Shah P, Moles DR, Parekh S, Ashley P, Siddik D. Evaluation of pediatric dentistry guidelines using the AGREE instrument. Pediatr Dent. 2011;33:120-9.
London SD, Chamut S, Fontelo P, Iafolla T, Dye BA. Assessment of the quality of current American dental association clinical practice guidelines. JDR Clin Trans Res. 2022;2:23800844221083563.
San Martin-Galindo L, Rodríguez-Lozano FJ, Abalos-Labruzzi C, Niederman R. European fissure sealant guidelines: assessment using AGREE II. Int J Dent Hyg. 2017;15:37-45.
Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021;372:n71.
Brouwers MC, Kho ME, Browman GP, Burgers JS, Cluzeau F, Feder G, et al. AGREE II: advancing guideline development, reporting, and evaluation in health care. Prev Med. 2010;51:421-4.
Ciapponi A, Tapia-López E, Virgilio S, Bardach A. The quality of clinical practice guidelines for preoperative care using the AGREE II instrument: a systematic review. Syst Rev. 2020;9:159.
Ghazal S, Ridha Z, D'Aguanno K, Nassim D, Quaiattini A, Netchiporouk E, et al. Treatment guidelines for atopic dermatitis since the approval of Dupilumab: a systematic review and quality appraisal using AGREE-II. Front Med (Lausanne). 2022;9:821871.
Lei R, Li Y, Zhou D, Hu X, Jiang X. Quality appraisal of clinical practice guidelines on physical restraints in ICU: a systematic review. Ann Palliat Med. 2022;11:774-83.
Bargeri S, Iannicelli V, Castellini G, Cinquini M, Gianola S. AGREE II appraisals of clinical practice guidelines in rehabilitation showed poor reporting and moderate variability in quality ratings when users apply different cuff-offs: a methodological study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2021;139:222-31.
AGREE-REX Research Team. The Appraisal of Guidelines Research & Evaluation-Recommendation EXcellence (AGREE-REX). [cited 2021 May 03]. Available from: https://www.agreetrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/AGREE-REX-2019.pdf
Levin L, Day PF, Hicks L, O'Connell A, Fouad AF, Bourguignon C, et al. International Association of Dental Traumatology guidelines for the management of traumatic dental injuries: general introduction. Dent Traumatol. 2020;36:309-13.
Fouad AF, Abbott PV, Tsilingaridis G, Cohenca N, Lauridsen E, Bourguignon C, et al. International Association of Dental Traumatology guidelines for the management of traumatic dental injuries: 2. Avulsion of permanent teeth. Dent Traumatol. 2020;36:331-42.
Bourguignon C, Cohenca N, Lauridsen E, Flores MT, O'Connell AC, Day PF, et al. International Association of Dental Traumatology guidelines for the management of traumatic dental injuries: 1. Fractures and luxations. Dent Traumatol. 2020;36:314-30.
Day PF, Flores MT, O'Connell AC, Abbott PV, Tsilingaridis G, Fouad AF, et al. International association of dental traumatology guidelines for the management of traumatic dental injuries: 3. Injuries in the primary dentition. Dent Traumatol. 2020;36:343-59.
Cagetti MG, Marcoli PA, Berengo M, Cascone P, Cordone L, Defabianis P, et al. Italian guidelines for the prevention and management of dental trauma in children. Ital J Pediatr. 2019;45:157.
Oral Health Programme-Ministry of Oral Health Malaysia. Management of avulsed permanent anterior teeth. Ministry of Oral Health Malaysia [cited 2021 Dec 23]. Available from: https://www.moh.gov.my/moh/resources/Penerbitan/CPG/Dental%20&%20Oral/CPG_Avulsed_Permanent_Anterior_Teeth_(Third_Ed)_2019_07042021.pdf
G-I-N Public Working Group. New digital guidelines international network (G-I-N) PUBLIC toolkit: patient and public involvement in guidelines. [cited 2022 Apr 18]. Available from: https://g-i-n.net/new-digital-gin-public-toolkit-patient-and-public-involvement-in-guidelines/
Amer YS, Elzalabany MM, Omar TI, Ibrahim AG, Dowidar NL. The ‘adapted ADAPTE’: an approach to improve utilization of the ADAPTE guideline adaptation resource toolkit in the Alexandria Center for Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines. J Eval Clin Pract. 2015;21:1095-106.
Schünemann HJ, Wiercioch W, Etxeandia I, Falavigna M, Santesso N, Mustafa R, et al. Guidelines 2.0: systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise. CMAJ. 2014;186:E123-42.
Brouwers MC, Kerkvliet K, Spithoff K, AGREE Next Steps Consortium. The AGREE reporting checklist: a tool to improve reporting of clinical practice guidelines. BMJ. 2016;352:i1152.
Kenny KP, Day PF, Sharif MO, Parashos P, Lauridsen E, Feldens CA, et al. What are the important outcomes in traumatic dental injuries? An international approach to the development of a core outcome set. Dent Traumatol. 2018;34:4-11.
Sharif MO, Tejani-Sharif A, Kenny K, Day PF. A systematic review of outcome measures used in clinical trials of treatment interventions following traumatic dental injuries. Dent Traumatol. 2015;31:422-8.
Herrmann A, Lenzer B, Müller BS, Danquah I, Nadeau KC, Muche-Borowski C, et al. Integrating planetary health into clinical guidelines to sustainably transform health care. Lancet Planet Health. 2022;6:e184-5.
Saikia A, Muthu MS, Orenuga OO, Mossey P, Ousehal L, Yan S, et al. Systematic review of clinical practice guidelines for Oral health in children with cleft lip and palate. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2022;59:800-14.
Ministry of Health: Shaping Fiji's Health. Clinical Practice guideline for the management of dental trauma. [cited 2021 Dec 23]. Available from: https://www.health.gov.fj/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Management-of-Dental-Trauma.doc.pdf
American Association of Endodontists. Guide to clinical endodontics. 6th ed. Chicago, IL: American Association of Endodontists; 2013.
Martínez García L, Arévalo-Rodríguez I, Solà I, et al. Strategies for monitoring and updating clinical practice guidelines: a systematic review. Implement Sci. 2012;7:109.