Census Tracts Are Not Neighborhoods: Addressing Spatial Misalignment in Studies Examining the Impact of Historical Redlining on Present-day Health Outcomes.
Journal
Epidemiology (Cambridge, Mass.)
ISSN: 1531-5487
Titre abrégé: Epidemiology
Pays: United States
ID NLM: 9009644
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
01 11 2023
01 11 2023
Historique:
medline:
29
9
2023
pubmed:
21
9
2023
entrez:
21
9
2023
Statut:
ppublish
Résumé
Research examining the effects of historical redlining on present-day health outcomes is often complicated by the misalignment of contemporary census boundaries with the neighborhood boundaries drawn by the US Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) in the 1930s. Previous studies have used different approaches to assign historical HOLC grades to contemporary geographies, but how well they capture redlining exposure is unknown. Our analysis included 7711 residences identified in the Multiple Listing Service database in Atlanta, Georgia (2017-2022). We evaluated the classification of HOLC grade assignment (A, B, C, D, or ungraded) when assigning exposure under four area-level approaches (centroid, majority land area, weighted score, and highest HOLC) compared with using complete address data (gold standard). We additionally compared approaches across three 2020 census geographies (tract, block group, and block). When comparing the use of census tracts to complete address data, sensitivity was highest for the weighted score approach, which correctly identified 77% of residences in truly A-D graded neighborhoods as compared with the majority land area (44%), centroid (54%), and highest HOLC (59%) approaches. Regarding specificity, the majority land area approach best-classified residences in truly ungraded neighborhoods (93%) as compared with the weighted score (65%), centroid (81%), and highest HOLC (54%) approaches. Classification improved regardless of approach when using census block compared with the census tract. Misclassification of historical redlining exposure is inevitable when using contemporary census geographies rather than complete address data. This study provides a framework for assessing spatial misalignment and selecting an approach for classification.
Sections du résumé
BACKGROUND
Research examining the effects of historical redlining on present-day health outcomes is often complicated by the misalignment of contemporary census boundaries with the neighborhood boundaries drawn by the US Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) in the 1930s. Previous studies have used different approaches to assign historical HOLC grades to contemporary geographies, but how well they capture redlining exposure is unknown.
METHODS
Our analysis included 7711 residences identified in the Multiple Listing Service database in Atlanta, Georgia (2017-2022). We evaluated the classification of HOLC grade assignment (A, B, C, D, or ungraded) when assigning exposure under four area-level approaches (centroid, majority land area, weighted score, and highest HOLC) compared with using complete address data (gold standard). We additionally compared approaches across three 2020 census geographies (tract, block group, and block).
RESULTS
When comparing the use of census tracts to complete address data, sensitivity was highest for the weighted score approach, which correctly identified 77% of residences in truly A-D graded neighborhoods as compared with the majority land area (44%), centroid (54%), and highest HOLC (59%) approaches. Regarding specificity, the majority land area approach best-classified residences in truly ungraded neighborhoods (93%) as compared with the weighted score (65%), centroid (81%), and highest HOLC (54%) approaches. Classification improved regardless of approach when using census block compared with the census tract.
CONCLUSIONS
Misclassification of historical redlining exposure is inevitable when using contemporary census geographies rather than complete address data. This study provides a framework for assessing spatial misalignment and selecting an approach for classification.
Identifiants
pubmed: 37732846
doi: 10.1097/EDE.0000000000001646
pii: 00001648-990000000-00178
doi:
Types de publication
Journal Article
Research Support, N.I.H., Extramural
Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't
Langues
eng
Sous-ensembles de citation
IM
Pagination
817-826Subventions
Organisme : NCI NIH HHS
ID : R01 CA259192
Pays : United States
Informations de copyright
Copyright © 2023 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
Déclaration de conflit d'intérêts
The authors report no conflicts of interest.
Références
Nelson RK, Winling L, Marciano R, Connolly N, Ayers EL. Mapping Inequality: Redlining in New Deal America. Am Panor Atlas U S Hist Univ Richmond Digit Scholarsh Lab. Published online 2020. Available at: https://dsl.richmond.edu/panorama/redlining/#loc=11/33.754/-84.513&city=atlanta-ga&area=C9&text=downloads . Accessed 4 May 2022.
Hillier AE. Residential security maps and neighborhood appraisals: the home owners’ loan corporation and the case of Philadelphia. Soc Sci Hist. 2005;29:207–233.
Lee PN, Forey BA, Coombs KJ. Systematic review with meta-analysis of the epidemiological evidence in the 1900s relating smoking to lung cancer. BMC Cancer. 2012;12:385.
Krieger N, Wright E, Chen JT, Waterman PD, Huntley ER, Arcaya M. Cancer stage at diagnosis, historical redlining, and current neighborhood characteristics: breast, cervical, lung, and colorectal cancers, Massachusetts, 2001-2015. Am J Epidemiol. 2020;189:1065–1075.
Krieger N, Van Wye G, Huynh M, et al. Structural racism, historical redlining, and risk of preterm birth in New York City, 2013–2017. Am J Public Health. 2020;110:1046–1053.
Nardone A, Casey JA, Morello-Frosch R, Mujahid M, Balmes JR, Thakur N. Associations between historical residential redlining and current age-adjusted rates of emergency department visits due to asthma across eight cities in California: an ecological study. Lancet Planet Health. 2020;4:e24–e31.
Nardone A, Chiang J, Corburn J. Historic redlining and urban health today in US cities. Environ Justice. 2020;13:109–119.
Lynch EE, Malcoe LH, Laurent SE, Richardson J, Mitchell BC, Meier HCS. The legacy of structural racism: associations between historic redlining. SSM Popul Health. 2021;14:100793.
Jacoby SF, Dong B, Beard JH, Wiebe DJ, Morrison CN. The enduring impact of historical and structural racism on urban violence in Philadelphia. Soc Sci Med. 2018;199:87–95.
Benns M, Ruther M, Nash N, Bozeman M, Harbrecht B, Miller K. The impact of historical racism on modern gun violence: redlining in the city of Louisville, KY. Injury. 2020;51:2192–2198.
Hollenbach SJ, Thornburg LL, Glantz JC, Hill E. Associations between historically redlined districts and racial disparities in current obstetric outcomes. JAMA Netw Open. 2021;4:e2126707.
Li D, Newman GD, Wilson B, Zhang Y, Brown RD. Modeling the relationships between historical redlining, urban heat, and heat-related emergency department visits: an examination of 11 Texas cities. Environ Plan B Urban Anal City Sci. 2022;49:933–952.
Li M, Yuan F. Historical redlining and resident exposure to COVID-19: a study of New York City. Race Soc Probl. 2022;14:85–100.
McClure E, Feinstein L, Cordoba E, et al. The legacy of redlining in the effect of foreclosures on detroit residents’ self-rated health. Health Place. 2019;55:9–19.
Walker K. tigris: Load Census TIGER/Line Shapefiles. Published online 2022. Available at: https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=tigris
Meier HCS, Mitchell BC. Historic Redlining Scores for 2010 and 2020 US Census Tracts. Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor]; 2021. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3886/E141121V2 . Accessed 6 May 2022
US Census Bureau. Centers of the Population Computation for the United States: 1950-2020. US Department of Commerce. 2021:7. Available at: https://www.census.gov/geographies/reference-files/time-series/geo/centers-population.html . Accessed 26 April 2022
2020 TIGER/Line Shapefiles (machine-readable data files)/ prepared by the U.S. Census Bureau. Published online 2020. Available at: https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/technical-documentation/complete-technical-documentation/tiger-geo-line.2020.html
Meier H, Mitchell B, Richardson J, Lynch E, Edlebi J. The Lasting Impact of Historic “Redlining” on Neighborhood Health: Higher Prevalence of COVID-19 Risk Factors. National Community Reinvestment Coalition. 2020. Available at: https://ncrc.org/holc-health/ .
Richardson J, Mitchell B, Meier H, Lynch E, Edlebi J. Redlining and neighborhood health. Natl Community Reinvestment Coalit. Published online 2020. Available at: https://ncrc.org/holc-health/ . Accessed 4 May 2022.
Cambon J, Hernangómez D, Belanger C, Possenriede D. tidygeocoder: An R package for geocoding. J Open Source Softw. 2021;6:3544.
Mujahid MS, Gao X, Tabb LP, Morris C, Lewis TT. Historical redlining and cardiovascular health: the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2021;118:e2110986118.
Noelke C, Outrich M, Baek M, et al. Connecting past to present: examining different approaches to linking historical redlining to present day health inequities. PLoS One. 2022;17:e0267606.
Lane HM, Morello-Frosch R, Marshall JD, Apte JS. Historical redlining is associated with present-day air pollution disparities in US cities. Environ Sci Technol Lett. 2022;9:345–350.
Yland JJ, Wesselink AK, Lash TL, Fox MP. Misconceptions about the direction of bias from nondifferential misclassification. Am J Epidemiol. 2022;191:1485–1495.
Michney TM. How the city survey’s redlining maps were made: a closer look at HOLC’s mortgagee rehabilitation division. J Plan Hist. 2022;21:316–344.
Themetropoleblog. The Tyranny of the Map: Rethinking Redlining. The Metropole. Published November 3, 2022. Available at: https://themetropole.blog/2022/11/03/the-tyranny-of-the-map-rethinking-redlining/ . Accessed 20 March 2023.
Swope CB, Hernández D, Cushing LJ. The relationship of historical redlining with present-day neighborhood environmental and health outcomes: a scoping review and conceptual model. J Urban Health. 2022;99:959–983.
Wien S, Miller AL, Kramer MR. Structural racism theory, measurement, and methods: a scoping review. Front Public Health. 2023;11:1069476.