Speculum self-insertion: an alternative method for gynaecological examination?

BACKGROUND

Speculum examination is an intrusive practice in the clinical care of women. It requires privacy and patients may experience discomfort or anxiety related to the procedure, which can result in delays or avoidance of necessary healthcare. Speculum self-insertion originated in the United States in the 1970s as part of the self-help movement. However, this clinical practice is largely unknown among healthcare providers and has rarely been assessed.

AIM

This study investigates the women's views and healthcare providers' experiences of the self-insertion method.

METHOD

A qualitative study was conducted between December 2021 and October 2022, including fieldwork combining semi-structured interviews (10 women) and focus groups associated with individual interviews of 13 healthcare providers. The data collected were independently coded by 2 authors and analysed using an inductive approach and grounded theory method.

RESULTS

Speculum self-insertion was described as a way to decrease discomfort and facilitate speculum insertion. Self-insertion was proposed as a means of allowing women to participate in the examination, reducing their vulnerability against power imbalances in the doctor-patient relationship. Both patients and healthcare providers have reported that speculum self-insertion is a method that can contribute to improving trust and communication during the examination.

CONCLUSION

The practice of speculum self-insertion during the consultation is an alternative to traditional practitioner insertion and may be offered to all women by any practitioner who wishes to use this technique.

The use of a speculum is common in gynaecological consultations and most women are likely to encounter this tool during a medical examination. Several studies have already shown that this examination can cause pain and anxiety. Speculum self-insertion is not widely used and consists of allowing the woman to insert the speculum herself while being assisted by the practitioner. A study was conducted with 10 women and 13 healthcare providers to evaluate this technique and its impact on women’s healthcare. This technique reduces the discomfort that can be felt during the examination. The woman will regain control of her body during the examination and this technique will reduce the hierarchical relationship felt by some women. A discussion about the gynaecological examination and women’s healthcare is created during the consultation. Even if this technique does not seem to be suitable for all women, routinely offering self-insertion allows the healthcare provider to adapt to each woman and to her choice. The proposal of speculum self-insertion is an alternative technique that can improves women’s feelings and their overall health.

Informations de copyright

© The Author(s) 2024. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: [e-mail].