A multicentre, randomised controlled trial to compare the clinical and cost-effectiveness of Lee Silverman Voice Treatment versus standard NHS Speech and Language Therapy versus control in Parkinson's disease: a study protocol for a randomised controlled trial.
Clinical Trials, Phase III as Topic
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Humans
Language Therapy
/ methods
Multicenter Studies as Topic
Parkinson Disease
/ complications
Quality of Life
Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic
Speech Therapy
/ methods
Surveys and Questionnaires
United Kingdom
Voice
Voice Disorders
/ etiology
Dysarthria
Idiopathic Parkinson’s disease
Lee Silverman voice treatment
Randomised controlled trial
Speech and language therapy
Journal
Trials
ISSN: 1745-6215
Titre abrégé: Trials
Pays: England
ID NLM: 101263253
Informations de publication
Date de publication:
27 May 2020
27 May 2020
Historique:
received:
19
02
2020
accepted:
27
04
2020
entrez:
29
5
2020
pubmed:
29
5
2020
medline:
20
2
2021
Statut:
epublish
Résumé
Parkinson's disease (PD) affects approximately 145,519 people in the UK. Speech impairments are common with a reported prevalence of 68%, which increase physical and mental demands during conversation, reliance on family and/or carers, and the likelihood of social withdrawal reducing quality of life. In the UK, two approaches to Speech and Language Therapy (SLT) intervention are commonly available: National Health Service (NHS) SLT or Lee Silverman Voice Treatment (LSVT LOUD®). NHS SLT is tailored to the individuals' needs per local practice typically consisting of six to eight weekly sessions; LSVT LOUD® comprises 16 sessions of individual treatment with home-based practice over 4 weeks. The evidence-base for their effectiveness is inconclusive. PD COMM is a phase III, multicentre, three-arm, unblinded, randomised controlled trial. Five hundred and forty-six people with idiopathic PD, reporting speech or voice problems will be enrolled. We will exclude those with a diagnosis of dementia, laryngeal pathology or those who have received SLT for speech problems in the previous 2 years. Following informed consent and completion of baseline assessments, participants will be randomised in a 1:1:1 ratio to no-intervention control, NHS SLT or LSVT LOUD® via a central computer-generated programme, using a minimisation procedure with a random element, to ensure allocation concealment. Participants randomised to the intervention groups will start treatment within 4 (NHS SLT) or 7 (LSVT LOUD®) weeks of randomisation. Voice Handicap Index (VHI) total score at 3 months. Secondary outcomes include: VHI subscales, Parkinson's Disease Questionnaire-39; Questionnaire on Acquired Speech Disorders; EuroQol-5D-5 L; ICECAP-O; resource utilisation; adverse events and carer quality of life. Mixed-methods process and health economic evaluations will take place alongside the trial. Assessments will be completed before randomisation and at 3, 6 and 12 months after randomisation. The trial started in December 2015 and will run for 77 months. Recruitment will take place in approximately 42 sites around the UK. The trial will test the hypothesis that SLT is effective for the treatment of speech or voice problems in people with PD compared to no SLT. It will further test whether NHS SLT or LSVT LOUD® provide greater benefit and determine the cost-effectiveness of both interventions. International Standard Randomised Controlled Trials Number (ISRCTN) Registry, ID: 12421382. Registered on 18 April 2016.
Sections du résumé
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
Parkinson's disease (PD) affects approximately 145,519 people in the UK. Speech impairments are common with a reported prevalence of 68%, which increase physical and mental demands during conversation, reliance on family and/or carers, and the likelihood of social withdrawal reducing quality of life. In the UK, two approaches to Speech and Language Therapy (SLT) intervention are commonly available: National Health Service (NHS) SLT or Lee Silverman Voice Treatment (LSVT LOUD®). NHS SLT is tailored to the individuals' needs per local practice typically consisting of six to eight weekly sessions; LSVT LOUD® comprises 16 sessions of individual treatment with home-based practice over 4 weeks. The evidence-base for their effectiveness is inconclusive.
METHODS/DESIGN
METHODS
PD COMM is a phase III, multicentre, three-arm, unblinded, randomised controlled trial. Five hundred and forty-six people with idiopathic PD, reporting speech or voice problems will be enrolled. We will exclude those with a diagnosis of dementia, laryngeal pathology or those who have received SLT for speech problems in the previous 2 years. Following informed consent and completion of baseline assessments, participants will be randomised in a 1:1:1 ratio to no-intervention control, NHS SLT or LSVT LOUD® via a central computer-generated programme, using a minimisation procedure with a random element, to ensure allocation concealment. Participants randomised to the intervention groups will start treatment within 4 (NHS SLT) or 7 (LSVT LOUD®) weeks of randomisation.
PRIMARY OUTCOME
METHODS
Voice Handicap Index (VHI) total score at 3 months. Secondary outcomes include: VHI subscales, Parkinson's Disease Questionnaire-39; Questionnaire on Acquired Speech Disorders; EuroQol-5D-5 L; ICECAP-O; resource utilisation; adverse events and carer quality of life. Mixed-methods process and health economic evaluations will take place alongside the trial. Assessments will be completed before randomisation and at 3, 6 and 12 months after randomisation. The trial started in December 2015 and will run for 77 months. Recruitment will take place in approximately 42 sites around the UK.
DISCUSSION
CONCLUSIONS
The trial will test the hypothesis that SLT is effective for the treatment of speech or voice problems in people with PD compared to no SLT. It will further test whether NHS SLT or LSVT LOUD® provide greater benefit and determine the cost-effectiveness of both interventions.
TRIAL REGISTRATION
BACKGROUND
International Standard Randomised Controlled Trials Number (ISRCTN) Registry, ID: 12421382. Registered on 18 April 2016.
Identifiants
pubmed: 32460885
doi: 10.1186/s13063-020-04354-7
pii: 10.1186/s13063-020-04354-7
pmc: PMC7251680
doi:
Types de publication
Clinical Trial Protocol
Comparative Study
Journal Article
Langues
eng
Sous-ensembles de citation
IM
Pagination
436Subventions
Organisme : Department of Health
ID : 10/135/02
Pays : United Kingdom
Organisme : Chief Scientist Office
ID : SCAF/18/01
Pays : United Kingdom
Organisme : Health Technology Assessment Programme
ID : 10/135/02
Investigateurs
A Church
(A)
A Davey
(A)
C Gallagher
(C)
A Conroy
(A)
S Bailey
(S)
B Done
(B)
D Davies
(D)
S Sveinbjornsdottir
(S)
M Kasti
(M)
K Allen
(K)
J Colnet
(J)
J Riches
(J)
L Kittridge
(L)
L Morris
(L)
C Waszkiewicz
(C)
V Lyell
(V)
V Page
(V)
N Bassford
(N)
H Rayner
(H)
E Henderson
(E)
S Abraham
(S)
J V Hindle
(JV)
S Jones
(S)
P Martin-Forbes
(P)
C Watkins
(C)
A Roberts
(A)
E Newcombe
(E)
L Bibby
(L)
L Matthews
(L)
J Roberts
(J)
S Thomas
(S)
H Hawthorne
(H)
K Clewley
(K)
S Lord
(S)
J Roberts
(J)
G Bretag
(G)
S Noble
(S)
D McGhee
(D)
H Mcclure
(H)
A Ling Zhi Teo
(ALZ)
R Wheeldon
(R)
C Wilkinson
(C)
M Oprea
(M)
G Van Duyvenvoorde
(G)
N Wilson
(N)
L Evans
(L)
R Belshaw
(R)
A Clarke
(A)
M Turner
(M)
C Thompson
(C)
R Saha
(R)
J Aram
(J)
D Mullan
(D)
J Newman
(J)
K Micabel
(K)
H Robinson
(H)
K Chick
(K)
J Gaylard
(J)
J Cochrane
(J)
E C Thomas
(EC)
A Kissick
(A)
P Wright
(P)
B Mohamed
(B)
S Mahon
(S)
T Williams
(T)
S Appleton
(S)
N Elliott
(N)
L Evans
(L)
J Ridley
(J)
A Funaki
(A)
P Daly
(P)
J Hackworth
(J)
K Timms
(K)
L Evison
(L)
A Bajracharya
(A)
M Silverdale
(M)
K Andrews
(K)
A Davies
(A)
R Bedford
(R)
A Jones
(A)
D Mournfield
(D)
L Howieson
(L)
V Price
(V)
J Hunter
(J)
A Baggs
(A)
L Evans
(L)
R Norton
(R)
M Holland
(M)
K Pointon
(K)
S Kulkarni
(S)
S Bobeldijk
(S)
S Beames
(S)
J Cavanagh
(J)
S Sudlow
(S)
G Lennox
(G)
R Whittaker
(R)
D Nelson
(D)
S Pegler
(S)
C Drayson
(C)
P Turner
(P)
J Stockwell
(J)
T Andrews
(T)
E White
(E)
E Turner
(E)
T Burnay
(T)
C Hickey
(C)
S Warner
(S)
R Buccoliero
(R)
C Isles
(C)
C Stemp
(C)
J Guy
(J)
C Bennett
(C)
S Smith
(S)
P Randall
(P)
L Ware
(L)
J Cann
(J)
L Sautin
(L)
S Grobler
(S)
S Adjei
(S)
A Hankin
(A)
D Ovayolu
(D)
M Dobbs
(M)
O Joyce
(O)
R Humphreys
(R)
A Jha
(A)
C Holbrook
(C)
K Rowsell
(K)
F Johnson
(F)
H Thornley
(H)
S Conway
(S)
C James
(C)
S Murrow
(S)
M Hughes
(M)
K Pope
(K)
C MacPhee
(C)
E Williams
(E)
R Hughes
(R)
A Evans
(A)
A Richmond
(A)
K Pilborough
(K)
K Campbell
(K)
S E Davies
(SE)
A Taylor
(A)
S Thomas
(S)
D Asandei
(D)
T Majeed
(T)
J Dawber
(J)
S Furey
(S)
A Oppetit
(A)
J Birt
(J)
M Hare
(M)
V Fleming
(V)
A Timoroksa
(A)
H Al-Nufoury
(H)
S Sharp
(S)
L Freimann
(L)
I Mavroudis
(I)
J Alty
(J)
E Richfield
(E)
J Harrison
(J)
V Smith
(V)
T Joyce
(T)
J Bamford
(J)
S Jamieson
(S)
J Cosgrove
(J)
S Butterworth
(S)
E Sacre
(E)
L Makawa
(L)
P Duggan-Carter
(P)
C Arnold
(C)
K Brown
(K)
P Mpofu
(P)
C Joyce
(C)
S Henderson
(S)
C Wiseman
(C)
L Hyne
(L)
B Stevens
(B)
A Wood
(A)
D Holland
(D)
V Smith
(V)
J Juada
(J)
S Molloy
(S)
C Pavel
(C)
M Dhanarante
(M)
T Adedoyin
(T)
C Rowbottom
(C)
L Little
(L)
R Choudhury
(R)
L Prados
(L)
A Kelly
(A)
R Eggers
(R)
T Saifee
(T)
P Poku
(P)
L Niepage
(L)
D Ahearn
(D)
A Fountain
(A)
A Curran
(A)
A Watt
(A)
M Wilson
(M)
A Anderson
(A)
M Graham
(M)
J Taylor
(J)
P Hewat
(P)
S Donaldson
(S)
H Moores-Poole
(H)
C Angus
(C)
S Coull
(S)
R Davy
(R)
A Gilmour-Graham
(A)
T Mcilroy
(T)
A Kendall
(A)
S Pal
(S)
E Messeder
(E)
D Thomson
(D)
V Johnston
(V)
P Raby
(P)
S Kinnear
(S)
P F Smith
(PF)
S Wishart
(S)
D Grosset
(D)
J Burns
(J)
A L Cunnington
(AL)
E Newman
(E)
C Vennard
(C)
C Dalton
(C)
T Murphy
(T)
G Ralph
(G)
A Ritchie
(A)
C Nelson
(C)
A McEntee
(A)
P Fowley
(P)
H Hare
(H)
G Beaton
(G)
M Wilson
(M)
D McDonald
(D)
J Finlayson
(J)
A Donaldson
(A)
S Sutherland
(S)
S Bramley
(S)
C Dunn
(C)
M Wallis
(M)
S Hewitt
(S)
H Morgan
(H)
A Falconer
(A)
L Peacock
(L)
A McAlpine
(A)
C McBrearty
(C)
A Lowe
(A)
N Findlay
(N)
A Adam
(A)
C Tearney
(C)
J Picken
(J)
K MacKenzie
(K)
L McCallum
(L)
L Smith
(L)
M Sidney
(M)
P Downie
(P)
L Donnelly
(L)
R McAllister
(R)
S Campbell
(S)
S Maclachlan
(S)
L Shearer
(L)
K Campbell
(K)
G Duncan
(G)
S Marrinan
(S)
M Dewar
(M)
J Kerr
(J)
L Killin
(L)
A Peters
(A)
A Stewart
(A)
T Daniels
(T)
A Darbyshire
(A)
I McCoy
(I)
U Duff
(U)
F Young
(F)
S Orr
(S)
C Telford
(C)
D Fraser
(D)
S Borthwick
(S)
H Bailey
(H)
L Karbownicki
(L)
E McLeod
(E)
D Sutherland
(D)
E Sammler
(E)
L Whyte
(L)
C Young
(C)
L Gillies
(L)
L Gall
(L)
J Dallas
(J)
L Cassidy
(L)
E Letham
(E)
V Salisbury
(V)
L Anderson
(L)
C Hutton
(C)
S Waggett
(S)
D Anderson
(D)
A Mcgee
(A)
S Cooper
(S)
G Mamutse
(G)
A Niruban
(A)
A Bath
(A)
A Wiltshire
(A)
M Harmer
(M)
C Wright
(C)
J Graham
(J)
K Richardson
(K)
J Tyler
(J)
L Isaacs
(L)
N Crow
(N)
S Pinnell
(S)
W Neale
(W)
L Maloney
(L)
R Weller
(R)
K Young
(K)
C Squire
(C)
A Whone
(A)
Y Hernandez
(Y)
H Findlay
(H)
K King
(K)
L Gethin
(L)
S Ticehurst
(S)
A Swift
(A)
J Short
(J)
J Dean
(J)
C Westcott
(C)
K Thomas
(K)
S Cottrell
(S)
D Kruszynska
(D)
S Kamath
(S)
Q Ma
(Q)
J Hall
(J)
R Wilson
(R)
H Goodhand
(H)
K Mellows
(K)
L J Cottam
(LJ)
T Behan
(T)
J Gibson
(J)
E Lomas
(E)
J Kirk
(J)
L Smith
(L)
J Benson
(J)
J Raw
(J)
P Mulligan
(P)
A Ansari
(A)
R Irving
(R)
A Javed
(A)
S Hussain
(S)
L Johnson
(L)
R Joseph
(R)
J Brooke
(J)
J Melville
(J)
M McCormack
(M)
J Stockley
(J)
D Ganderton
(D)
A Cherriman
(A)
J Price
(J)
C Douglas
(C)
C Cooter
(C)
J Bushell
(J)
R Sheridan
(R)
C Browning
(C)
K Polverino
(K)
T Malone
(T)
S Jackson
(S)
A Foden
(A)
R James
(R)
S Hayes
(S)
L Roberts
(L)
E Davis
(E)
C Clarke
(C)
D Nicholl
(D)
A Majeed
(A)
M T Oo
(MT)
K Blachford
(K)
A Boughey
(A)
J Kaur
(J)
S Kaur
(S)
M Awan
(M)
S Rahman
(S)
J Round
(J)
D Gandecha
(D)
S Williams
(S)
S Dealing
(S)
H Moss
(H)
L Talbot
(L)
S Cooper
(S)
R Sophia
(R)
J Allen
(J)
S Cox
(S)
C Moreira
(C)
D Woolven
(D)
D Sharratt
(D)
E Foster
(E)
H Hurren
(H)
J Watson
(J)
S Northover
(S)
D Green
(D)
A Treloggen
(A)
C Pawley
(C)
K Beesley
(K)
K Milne
(K)
L Howard
(L)
S Craw
(S)
A Lewis
(A)
A Whitcher
(A)
C Vickers
(C)
T Russell
(T)
A Sykes
(A)
H Meikle
(H)
N Loraine
(N)
M Steiger
(M)
H Treloar
(H)
L Roebuck
(L)
M Taylor
(M)
R Nashed
(R)
J Garfield-Smith
(J)
S Mills
(S)
H Griffin
(H)
C Marshall
(C)
G De Selincourt
(G)
V Queen
(V)
M Stone
(M)
M Farrow-Jones
(M)
E Sturdy
(E)
K Almedilla
(K)
F Fitzsimmons
(F)
M Alison
(M)
F Rogers
(F)
B Reed
(B)
M Pinkney
(M)
S Jones
(S)
S Muzerengi
(S)
M Johnson
(M)
S Stafford
(S)
E Parmar
(E)
J Albutt
(J)
S Kaur
(S)
M Awan
(M)
S Rahman
(S)
K Leahy
(K)
T Allain
(T)
M Sritharan
(M)
A Daniell
(A)
K Kunsteinaite
(K)
S Slade
(S)
F Pimbblet
(F)
C Killourhey
(C)
E Wales
(E)
C Hughes
(C)
G Horsfield
(G)
L Mercer
(L)
Z Roberts
(Z)
K Stock
(K)
M Evans
(M)
S Boyd
(S)
L King
(L)
J Birch
(J)
S Anderson
(S)
C Evans
(C)
N Stapleton
(N)
U Magennis
(U)
R Vernall
(R)
Références
J Health Serv Res Policy. 2008 Oct;13 Suppl 3:31-7
pubmed: 18806190
Mov Disord. 2018 Nov;33(11):1777-1791
pubmed: 30264896
Neurology. 1967 May;17(5):427-42
pubmed: 6067254
Age Ageing. 2006 May;35(3):235-9
pubmed: 16540492
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1988 Jun;51(6):745-52
pubmed: 2841426
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1983 Aug;46(8):789
pubmed: 6886727
Codas. 2016 May 31;28(3):311-3
pubmed: 27253227
Lancet Neurol. 2018 Nov;17(11):939-953
pubmed: 30287051
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1983 Feb;46(2):140-4
pubmed: 6842217
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2001 Oct;71(4):493-8
pubmed: 11561033
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2007 May;16(2):95-107
pubmed: 17456888
Pract Neurol. 2017 Aug;17(4):266-274
pubmed: 28687681
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2011 Mar-Apr;46(2):189-201
pubmed: 21401817
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2017 Jun 22;26(2S):561-568
pubmed: 28654939
Neurology. 2003 Feb 11;60(3):498-500
pubmed: 12578936
Br J Disord Commun. 1990 Aug;25(2):183-94
pubmed: 2206966
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 Aug 15;(8):CD002812
pubmed: 22895930
Eur J Disord Commun. 1992;27(2):121-7
pubmed: 1446099
Brain Lang. 2006 May;97(2):123-34
pubmed: 16226803
J Speech Hear Res. 1995 Dec;38(6):1232-51
pubmed: 8747817
Trials. 2017 Aug 29;18(1):397
pubmed: 28851443
J Commun Disord. 2000 Jan-Feb;33(1):59-88
pubmed: 10665513
Folia Phoniatr Logop. 2008;60(1):11-9
pubmed: 18057906
Qual Life Res. 2011 Dec;20(10):1727-36
pubmed: 21479777
Br J Disord Commun. 1984 Dec;19(3):213-24
pubmed: 6508992
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1984 Mar;47(3):302-4
pubmed: 6707678
BMJ. 2014 Mar 07;348:g1687
pubmed: 24609605
Lancet. 2015 Aug 29;386(9996):896-912
pubmed: 25904081
Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2012 Jun;18(5):483-7
pubmed: 22321866
Age Ageing. 2012 Nov;41 Suppl 3:iii35-40
pubmed: 23144286
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1981 Oct 24;283(6299):1088
pubmed: 6794774
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2008 Jun;51(3):562-73
pubmed: 18506035
Folia Phoniatr Logop. 1994;46(1):9-17
pubmed: 8162135
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2007 Nov;78(11):1188-90
pubmed: 17400592
Mov Disord. 2001 Jan;16(1):79-83
pubmed: 11215597
Pilot Feasibility Stud. 2018 Jan 10;4:30
pubmed: 29344405
Ann Intern Med. 2013 Feb 5;158(3):200-7
pubmed: 23295957
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 Aug 15;(8):CD002814
pubmed: 22895931
Age Ageing. 1997 Sep;26(5):353-7
pubmed: 9351479